Evil only wins when it spreads. It can cause destruction, it can cause death—but those are consequences of its nature, not its victory. Not its goal. The danger of evil, the purpose of evil, is that it causes those who would oppose it to become evil also.
I kinda agree, but a huge number of things have changed from then to now or have happened that altered the scene:
COVID.
A sexual scandal that led to many high-profile people being fired or demoted.
The Shadowlands fiasco.
The first major WoW Exodus. It was so massive that Square Enix removed FF14 from stores because they didn't have enough servers to handle the intense influx of WoW refugees.
Many prominent WoW content creators either quit WoW or turned highly negative (remember, they create significant waves).
Metzen has been back for more than a year.
The Microsoft Deal.
The Proletariat Deal.
And so on.
The last four years since 2019 have been incredibly intense
Last edited by Dragon ANX; 2023-11-01 at 06:11 PM.
Sure, if you just really think the Titans need to be the end-all-be-all.
The point was to show that, upon going to a different reality in the same universe, we learn a few more things about it we wouldn't have learned before. Like, we weren't supposed to be behind that curtain, of course there'd be secrets there. The Titans probably never saw the Shadowlands either. Apart from, obviously, Argus.
The story you want works if you aren't trying to create a bigger narrative. Sorry man, that's just how it is.
Besides that, what exactly got "retconned out of oblivion" by the First Ones? We're literally doing more with the Titans right now, and it has nothing to do with the First Ones. Not because "they're deleting that lore" or anything but because it literally is irrelevant to the Titan's current developments. And in general. Like, I don't understand the ""anger"" here.
Like, they're basically a narrative device for "looking behind the curtain" and "it's a lot bigger out there than you think" and that's probably all they'll be unless we cover a different Zereth in a Void expansion. What's there to be pissed about? I don't know how to explain this further.
Last edited by Zankai27; 2023-11-01 at 06:10 PM.

The binary stuff, all together, seems too good to be true.
But it would certainly get WoW back on track.
So if it is karesh then I feel like ethereal are a given. I hope they're neutral but would probably be alliance because of velves.
In that case, hope horde gets ogres.
See what I wanna know is how Ka'resh fits into Khaz Algar/Avaloren and Earthen as a race?
Binary leak doesn't actually have K'aresh, it was a lead towards removing transmog restrictions.
It'd be a solid expansion all things considered.
Except... not really? In the previous lore, before the First Ones came around, the universe came about from Light and Void clashing.
This may be inaccurate, but if I recall, at first there was nothing. Then Light came into being. Light's existence created shadows for the first time, which coalesced into Void. Light and Shadow smashed into each other and the resultant explosion created The Great Dark Beyond, AKA the physical universe, alongside Arcane magic and the Twisting Nether which was a sort of twisted (heh) mirror reality, which came with Chaos magic.
You don't need a creator, sometimes thing can just happen.
Evil only wins when it spreads. It can cause destruction, it can cause death—but those are consequences of its nature, not its victory. Not its goal. The danger of evil, the purpose of evil, is that it causes those who would oppose it to become evil also.