The War Within 11.X Patches & World Soul Saga Speculation Thread

[Ersula]

debatable but thats because blizz cant keep their character motivations straight or write them clearly

They wrote a book about it.

[Cheezits]

I have a feeling that comic will end up being from the Bad Light/AU Draenor timeline.

[Khaza-R]

I don't think it was to shoehorn the Horde v Alliance stuff, but rather more of a design choice. Ashenvale is a BIG zone and a contested territory because of the Horde lumber mill from Warcraft 3. There wasn't much of a Horde vs Alliance narrative as much as it was Arch Druid Fandral Staghelm being one of the worst leaders to the Alliance, that he basically took Malfurion's role and had the Night Elves stay in Darnassus because it was all HIS idea.

If you really think about it, everything that people didn't like about the Night Elves going from Warcraft 3 to WoW could all be pointed towards Fandral Staghelm.

It was a very active choice by them to try and fit a race that was an entire army into a side note of the Alliance. They managed to do the same with the undead but that at least was explained by fragmenting the Forsaken from the Scourge.

Even Ashenvale being contested is kind of murky in lore. Grom is losing his fight in Ashvenvale and needs to drink Mannoroth's blood to win. He later kills Mannoroth and fel orcs disappear. Tyrande and Malfurion return to Ashenvale between the events of the battle for Hyjal and TFT. Clearly it was well within their ability and power to remove any orc from Ashenvale at that point.

[loras]

An archaic way of looking at patch content IMO but it's definitely one that's hammered into people's heads in WoW for some weird reason. Raiding is fun, raiding is cool and if you have the time & / or patience, even better for harder difficulties. But I've never bought that raids should be the only end-all or the sole focus of a patch. Dungeons, open world content, raids, smaller form factor events, world bosses, world events, etc. etc.

There are so many things that Blizzard are (most likely) going to be pushing into for the foreseeable future within WoW's end-game ecosystem.

Same honestly, frankly i've always advocated making gear available through different equivalent tracks without capping it off for arbitrary reasons.

[Eldryth]

I know, right? I've brought up old Anduin leading the Army of the Light in the final battle against the Shadow several times, and people keep crying "it's an old Legion comic! It's going to be retconned!"

I think they said at one point that that comic was just one possible future. I'm sure we'll get something like it, but I don't know about an exact match. I can definitely see Anduin being younger since it'd probably take some accelerated aging like Khadgar, a massive time skip, or time travel stuff to make him that old by Midnight.

[Woggmer]

So exactly how Shadowlands played out. Thrall and Baine sitting on their bums doing nothing through entire expansion. And it is a bait and switch. This game is based on 2 factions, and therefore it should at least attempt to give similar amount of story for both of them. And I don't see "do anything Alliance tells you to do" as a compelling story.
And Blizzard was able to provide separate questing experience in the past. So it's not like they cannot do it, it's that they don't bother to do it anymore. And story suffers becuase of that.

I hate to say it, but I'm afraid we might be too far gone to go back to that unless they decide to go that route in Midnight, but I honestly doubt it... With Tyrande, Malfurion, Greymane, Sylvanas, Thrall, and so on not leaders anymore, and Gallywix left the Horde entirely. Lilian Voss, Shandris, Calia Menethil, Tess Greymane, Baine, and many others as leaders there won't be any Alliance vs Horde stories to come. Especially since Shandris and Voss are friends and now Calia and Tess might work peace together between Gilneas and the Forsaken.

The only slight saving grace would be Turalyon, but we haven't seen him in ages to know what he's doing.

People wanted no faction tension like in BFA, so this is what we get as a result. We're not fighting each other anymore, but the bigger threat as always.

[Hitei]

I think they said at one point that that comic was just one possible future. I'm sure we'll get something like it, but I don't know about an exact match. I can definitely see Anduin being younger since it'd probably take some accelerated aging like Khadgar, a massive time skip, or time travel stuff to make him that old by Midnight.

The entire idea of this comic's scene is a farce, as is Metzen's hype-manning Midnight.

The void can't be banished forever, it's a fundamental part of the universe intended to be equal in the six part mix. It also innate arises from the presence of the Light. This idea that somehow the Light is going to win has been suggested a bunch of times to just be a zealous delusion that the Light specifically holds. It single-mindedly rejects the truth that the Void is the other side of the coin, and thinks that it's going to somehow permanently "win" and destroy it.

Midnight isn't gonna somehow end the Void's existence, or stop it from ever being a threat again, so its wholly possible that the comic future might still come to pass a long time from now, another misguided attempt where the Light thinks it's gonna win some final battle.

[Ersula]

The entire idea of this comic's scene is a farce, as is Metzen's hype-manning Midnight.

The void can't be banished forever, it's a fundamental part of the universe intended to be equal in the six part mix. It also innate arises from the presence of the Light. This idea that somehow the Light is going to win has been suggested a bunch of times to just be a zealous delusion that the Light specifically holds. It single-mindedly rejects the truth that the Void is the other side of the coin, and thinks that it's going to somehow permanently "win" and destroy it.

Midnight isn't gonna somehow end the Void's existence, or stop it from ever being a threat again, so its wholly possible that the comic future might still come to pass a long time from now, another misguided attempt where the Light thinks it's gonna win some final battle.

The Jailer seemed to disagree with any of the six cosmic forces being necessary. Also in retrospect you're right in this being the vaguest cop-out tease they never had any intention of bringing to fruition. There's no sign of what force they're even taking a stand against, since we had every reason to think they were facing the Burning Legion, what with the Draenei commonly referring to demonkind as "the shadow" even though they're part of a completely different sphere.

I'd like metzen to reestablish that Sargeras dipped into multiple cosmic forces. Rather than them recontectualizing everything using Sire Denathrius & the Jailer. So Sargeras drew his powers from the Discord sphere, he wasn't limited to it, exclusively. Sargeras had Void Walkers & Blood Magic & Dreadlords & the Scourge was originally a Burning Legion plot, but apparently it was all the Jailer actually.

The Naaru used shards of light to seed life on planets across the universe so obviously the cosmic forces were never purely homogenous.

[Hitei]

The Jailer seemed to disagree with any of the six cosmic forces being necessary. Also in retrospect you're right in this being the vaguest cop-out tease they never had any intention of bringing to fruition. There's no sign of what force they're even taking a stand against, since we had every reason to think they were facing the Burning Legion, what with the Draenei commonly referring to demonkind as "the shadow" even though they're part of a completely different sphere.

The Jailer's failure is itself direct evidence of the superiority of the balanced six forces. But also Anduin and Velen and a handful of Draenei in a dimensional ship aren't going to unwrite the Void from existence, including its own plane, and even if they did, the pattern is designed such that the Light itself naturally fades and leaves behind Void, so it'd just come back unless they are also wiping out the Light in its entirety.

They'd need something on par with a Zereth to attempt those sort of top level reality warping strategies, and if a Zereth was getting involved, the First Ones would have already engineered failsafes to prevent such an incursion from destabilizing the Pattern.

I agree that people assume too much of the comic's context. Varian is brought up, and Varian didn't die fighting the Void.

Regardless of what was originally intended to be happening, it could very easily be nudged any number of directions and re-contextualized. Maybe in Midnight we're left with a permanent Void Rift in Quel'thalas that Anduin and Velen are, in the future, finally going to force closed. Maybe in the far future they are helping the Ethereals retake K'aresh from the Void. Maybe in the far future, Anduin and Velen have been world-hopping, liberating fallen worlds from the remnants of the Legions' control, and they're finally approaching the end of that campaign.

[Ersula]

The Jailer's failure is itself direct evidence of the superiority of the balanced six forces.

Does it tho? The rest of the Death Pantheon just kinda ganged up on him.

[Hitei]

Does it tho? The rest of the Death Pantheon just kinda ganged up on him.

I would say yes. His entire plan ultimately hinged on borrowing Azeroth's power, a planet that represents the nexus of the six forces, and the Maw Walkers, as people of that nexus, proved superior to death's/the Maw's forces, and the forces using solely that pillar at nearly every turn. The only force the expansion really suggested that Death managed to stand against was Chaos, and there it was more about manipulating Chaos to use its plans to also benefit Death than actual superiority.

Considering that he only even managed to stand against the other members of his own Pantheon and the confines of the Maw by virtue of making use of tons of anima passed on from Life, and the influence of Chaos allowing for the arbiter construct to be disabled, I think he was woefully overestimating Death's potential.

[Lorgar Aurelian]

They will probably say this comic was from an alternative reality like time rifts in DF.

They already said at the start of BFA that it was just one of the many possible futures Velan has seen from his visions, so the chances of it happening and pretty non existent.

[Auxis]

I have a feeling that comic will end up being from the Bad Light/AU Draenor timeline.

Velen died in the AU, so the Velen in the comic would - at the very least - have to be the MU Velen.

[Cherry123]

I think they said at one point that that comic was just one possible future. I'm sure we'll get something like it, but I don't know about an exact match. I can definitely see Anduin being younger since it'd probably take some accelerated aging like Khadgar, a massive time skip, or time travel stuff to make him that old by Midnight.

virgins age faster and he's a super virgin

[Nathanyel]

Also, with the usual influential parties on Twitter crying about the lack of Horde, are we expecting devs to change it up? Because otherwise, they (not naming names) are going to shit up the community in a tantrum, which WoW really does not need right now.

First, WoW Twitter throws a tantrum about everything.

If 11.1 has a Goblin theme, that would offer plenty of Horde-"centric" stories, most notably Gazlowe oposing Gallywix.

Darnassus was only their home for 30 years. They moved away from Hyjal because literally no reason.

10. Teldrassil was planted in year 23, and burned in year 33.

The latest scandal on reddit is the shipping costs from US to Europe being so high for the 20th anniversary expac edition. No one cares that shipping prices worldwide have tripled since all the stuff in the middle East happened.

Wait, did EU people actually order from the US store? I was tempted to order from the UK one since it offered less shipping costs to Germany, but then I realized I'd probably have to pay customs on top of that, and worst case, travel to the other end of the city to collect it from the customs bureau (industrial area, shitty bus connection)

I agree with your point but I also believe Bobby Kotick Activision was an entity of metaphysical evil.

That's easy to think because of his... stereotypical "evil capitalist" appearance, but I doubt he was worse than other CEOs. To be absolutely clear, I'm not saying he wasn't as bad as we think, but that basically every CEO is as shitty as him, doing objectively evil things to squeeze money out - that is the literal job description, to maximize profits for the shareholders. As long as the scandals are suppressed or don't affect revenue too much, it's more lucrative to just keep doing it.

[allegrian]

They already said at the start of BFA that it was just one of the many possible futures Velan has seen from his visions, so the chances of it happening and pretty non existent.

It's sad that we are used to blizzard not caring about his own lore at all and just improvising from patch to patch since BFA. In the past, that comic would've been an interesting discussion topic and something to be hyped about. Now we just know blizzard didn't have anything planned and will ignore/retcon it, same goes with the jailer's "we're not prepare for what's to come".

I guess we can at least expect some care about story within the same expansion trilogy now, we'll see.

[Hitei]

It's sad that we are used to blizzard not caring about his own lore at all and just improvising from patch to patch since BFA. In the past, that comic would've been an interesting discussion topic and something to be hyped about. Now we just know blizzard didn't have anything planned and will ignore/retcon it, same goes with the jailer's "we're not prepare for what's to come".

This is exactly how they have always written. "In the past" was even worse.

[Ramz]

I hate to say it, but I'm afraid we might be too far gone to go back to that unless they decide to go that route in Midnight, but I honestly doubt it... With Tyrande, Malfurion, Greymane, Sylvanas, Thrall, and so on not leaders anymore, and Gallywix left the Horde entirely. Lilian Voss, Shandris, Calia Menethil, Tess Greymane, Baine, and many others as leaders there won't be any Alliance vs Horde stories to come. Especially since Shandris and Voss are friends and now Calia and Tess might work peace together between Gilneas and the Forsaken.

The only slight saving grace would be Turalyon, but we haven't seen him in ages to know what he's doing.

People wanted no faction tension like in BFA, so this is what we get as a result. We're not fighting each other anymore, but the bigger threat as always.

There is also Talanji and Rokhan the most vocal anti-Alliance Horde members, who also are absent for 2 expansions, Rokhan had a small cameo with that Tauren about that Tauren that was killed by centaur, and at the raid he was with Rexxar and Chen to invoke memberberries, but he doesn't say anything. I guess for the better.

Neutral stories are so lame annd unspired becuase they're not personal. You ask yourself questions "what I am doing even here?".

[Hitei]

Neutral stories are so lame annd unspired becuase they're not personal. You ask yourself questions "what I am doing even here?".

Hard disagree. I'd be asking that way more if I were tagging along with people as absolutely irrelevant as Rokhan. Khadgar quests are significantly less lame and more personal than that shit.

[Makorus]

There is also Talanji and Rokhan the most vocal anti-Alliance Horde members, who also are absent for 2 expansions, Rokhan had a small cameo with that Tauren about that Tauren that was killed by centaur, and at the raid he was with Rexxar and Chen to invoke memberberries, but he doesn't say anything. I guess for the better.

Neutral stories are so lame annd unspired becuase they're not personal. You ask yourself questions "what I am doing even here?".

And Horde stories about Trolls are personal to Orcs/Undead/Tauren/Blood Elves/Vulpera/Maghar/Highmountain/Pandaren/Goblins/Nightborne/Dracthyr how?

Just because the tooltip says "Horde" when you hover over a character doesn't mean the story is any more interesting.