Bring back bonus rolls

[huth]

Since raids and mythic0 are the only instances that has a hard cap on chances at loot each week, when you do a full clear there should be a bonus chest where everyone gets a random drop from the instance.

Make it a tier lower than normal for raid and i could actually get on board with that. I.e. first clear normal loot, all subsequent you get 1 guaranteed item of 1 difficulty lower. M+ chests are lower than the weekly reward as well.

M0 is a bit silly. You can just run a +2 for that, which isn't significantly more difficult.

[erifwodahs]

No. Random roll isnt good idea. RNG will kill it and make more annoyence. Bring some token instead. I mean a kind of currency (yes we love more currency) as exchanger for raid item. Correct one not random.

Doubloons like in SL S4, that was great

[LordVargK]

Please don't. The current system is more than fine.

[Lodreh]

The issue is predetermined loot is always superior to RNG. I have been playing the pixel remasters of Final Fantasy... you could buy most gear from shops. If you opened the right treasure chest you would get a certain upgrade. It was not RNG... that chest always contained that piece of gear... RNG gearing needs to go the way of the dodo. It was nice but it's time to go. For better or worse we are mercenaries. We do the job, we get paid... not a chance for pay... but an actual, tangible reward. Otherwise is just frustration.

[czarek]

They're not going to remove the RNG. Even your currency would only buy you a box of raid loot, similar to the ones given on TW and Dungeon weeks. Maybe limited to a wing or something, but you're not going to get a specific item. They only did that in the final SL season because the loot pool would otherwise have been prohibitively large.

Not only. In season 1 you could obtain weapon for a token. Still better option than loot unwanted item. As i remember one token was from the quest. Beside this. As i saw they added weekly heroic dungeon quest with RNG box. Gearin up ways is a lot but the problem is again RNG. Some with good luck could gear up a toon in 1 week. Another one within a month couldnt. In season 1 i was gearin up my main priest for a months. When i decided to make some alts ive made warrior and gear him up over the priest ilvl in 2 weeks with great RNG lol. And thats curious becuause i think RNG work better for fresh toons or mid season. My mains are always loosers opposite to alts.

[huth]

Not only. In season 1 you could obtain weapon for a token. Still better option than loot unwanted item. As i remember one token was from the quest. Beside this. As i saw they added weekly heroic dungeon quest with RNG box. Gearin up ways is a lot but the problem is again RNG. Some with good luck could gear up a toon in 1 week. Another one within a month couldnt. In season 1 i was gearin up my main priest for a months. When i decided to make some alts ive made warrior and gear him up over the priest ilvl in 2 weeks with great RNG lol. And thats curious becuause i think RNG work better for fresh toons or mid season. My mains are always loosers opposite to alts.

It was only weapons and it was for an entirely different reason. It didn't really offer that much variation, either and the token itself was still RNG, being a regular drop.

[Thirtyrock]

Bring back personal loot for LFR.
Personal loot for raids who are less than half of the same guild.
Group Loot for raids with more than half of the same guild, unless they enable PL.

This is the best solution, IMO.

- - - Updated - - -

Except this cathalyst is capped to 6 charges per character in season 2 ? Vault is okish if RNGeasus bless you. If not its annoyence. I would rather to collect token or smth.

My understanding was that it was capped at 6 at a time, but you kept earning at the same rate if you spent them. Is that not the case?

--

I find the Vault to be a lot more satisfying than bonus rolls were. I like that I have options and I can control how MANY options I get by what I choose to do that week. I can get more options by spending more time in game. That's better than being limited to 2 rolls per week regardless.

I would like to see some sort of gear for currency, like let us just buy 1/8 gear with 20 of the relevant crests or something, just in case someone has REALLY bad luck (I pulled 20 out of the air, it might be way too much or not enough, just a concept).

[huth]

My understanding was that it was capped at 6 at a time, but you kept earning at the same rate if you spent them. Is that not the case?

Basically the same as it was in Season 1, except there's no quest, you just get the charge each weekly reset. So 1 charge per week, maximum 6 charges stored at once.

[Thirtyrock]

Basically the same as it was in Season 1, except there's no quest, you just get the charge each weekly reset. So 1 charge per week, maximum 6 charges stored at once.

Ok, that's what I thought. I think people are seeing the 6 charges and thinking that's the final number they'll get over the whole season.

[Spey]

Cannot agree or disagree, but the problem when healers rolling on DPS trinkets stays.

[Soon-TM]

Bonus rolls were fun, but as with many other fun things, they were axed so that hardcore raiders weren't Forced™ to get the corresponding tokens.