Would WoW work if it didn't have any retention of player progress?

[AudibleEscalation]

But you know why they won't do it?

Yes. We know exactly why they won't do it.

- - - Updated - - -

I haven't been online (or at least subbed) for 2 years.

That was their point.

[epigramx]

you continue to obsess

I rarely visit the forum once a week. I know a strawman is a very desirable "argument", when you have no good argument.

[NineSpine]

I envision a WoW format that you play in first person and use guns to shoot people during WWII.

I consider it a more important format than classic; classic is just the normal game with nostalgia; make actually a new format for a change.

But you know why they won't do it? Because it drops the illusion "epicz" are important and then the whole time-wasting of grinding falls like a house of cards.

[Calfredd]

I rarely visit the forum once a week. I know a strawman is a very desirable "argument", when you have no good argument.

Is that why you use them so often to deflect criticisms of your ideas?

[epigramx]

Is that why you use them so often to deflect criticisms of your ideas?

"No you" doesn't work either, when it makes no sense.