Originally Posted by
Lesane
4/5 vengeful isn't even 100 resilience, for the warrior set at most it's 24+24+25+22 (and this is if you're not wearing gloves, which is dumb because it has the hamstring bonus), that is a grand total of 95 resilience. You need 400 to even counter the damage debuff from berserker stance when it comes to DoT's. And the ring from Hydross is terribad, I would rather wear the S2/S3 combo, other than that it's not like it's hard to kill Hydross... I bet there are tons of guilds willing to sell you that mediocre ring for a couple of hundred gold.
Duels don't prove much. Especially not warrior vs. warrior duels. It's about overall performance in PVP. Ok grats you might have an edge over another warrior in toe to toe melee (which I seriously doubt because the much better survivability stats of the PVP geared warrior will shine more in long battles), but that's all. Against any class with on demand burst damage you can prepare to drop like a fly.
As for Tsunami Talisman being 'much better'? You gain 10 hit rating, 6 crit rating and 40 extra AP when it procs. The Hourglass is worth at least 75% of the power the Talisman has. Better? Yes. Much better? No. A 33% increase on 1 slot of the entire 13 or whatever it is won't make or break a game.
And Narzania, I don't see what you try to prove with listing those items. Please note how none of those items aside from the ring and trinket have hit rating. Most lack crit rating as well. They have 0 resilience in total and much lower stamina. Not only that but you won't have the insanely powerful set bonuses from the arena set. You're simply a fool if you're gonna PVP in the gear you just listed. I won't completely deny that he MIGHT have an edge over another warrior when they are fighting EACHOTHER but how many times do you seriously see warriors fight eachother all the time? There are more things in the game like this, I bet all rogues would wear their PVE gear vs. warlocks if they were allowed to but vs. warriors they would get completely demolished. For overall PVP performance, the PVP items are king, simple as that.