Originally Posted by
SkillOverKill
I don't think most people realize what a massive mitigation buff would be necessary for us to have 'any' actual staying power in PvP currently. A lot of you are talking about this like if they would just stick 10% more melee mitigation on shadowform we'd be good to go - that's not the case.
The reality is if they stuck 50% more melee mitigation on shadowform, we'd still get chain CC'd to death, it'd just take twice as long. (let's see, 6s becomes 12s).
The ONLY way to make shadow viable right now in Arenas is to give us a way to get back to range once we are in melee - something like blink seems the only real option. It escapes us from the chain-CC/instagib and allows us to actually put up some dots again (which, remember are easy as hell to dispel since we have zero dispel protection).
If they gave us 30% dispel protection on our dots, what we're really saying is the 3 seconds it takes to apply 3 dots for us currently, can be removed in 3 seconds - before a single one of our dots actually ticks, if they're dispeller has my reaction speed. A good heal partner sees you casting VT and starts fingering their dispel key - if they do - even with 30% dispel protection we won't deal any damage for the 2k mana we burn putting them up (not to mention effectively stunning us for the duration since we can't move while casting and we aren't accomplishing anything like dispelling our partner or selves for that period).
The whole reason mages are any threat in melee where we are not is because they have nova, chill, and blink - escaping that they have ice block - all of which allow them to get back to range from melee where they can resume whooping ass. What's more, mage dps is instant, it's not easily-anticipated, dispellable dots which would require an absolute moron on the enemy team to ignore for their full duration. We need movement, not mitigation, not protection - movement is king - movement so we can flay something or blast something or dispel something without getting gibbed by the rogue up our ass or the paladin who views Dispersion and shield, merely as us silencing ourselves because they don't stop their damage anyways.