I'm making this post to try to focus all the discussion of Holy pally pvp spec's into one main thread, I see many different posts that discuss it but their not very well titled or overlooked. Please keep in mind I'm new to both these forums as a poster and new to Holy pally pvp, i used to mainly pve, but have found myself more enjoying pvp.
As you all probably are already debating, is 3.1 going to be Holy/prot or Holy/Ret?
I myself am still even after hours of playing with talent calculators and messing around on the PTR am still finding myself in slump...The biggest issue i see with a Holy/Prot spec (Below - Just an example not fine tuned etc.) seems to be the fact that even though your saving IoF for those oh-so-fun insta-flash of lights, Your losing 8% crit from the ret tree, So while you may argue you still have DF for that Oh-Sh!t moment it's still relatively sketchy losing all that crit while saving a talent thats reliant on crit. But, at the same time if you look at these talents you gain through prot, the survival possiblities are absolutely incredible such as the 30% stun time reduction and then in 3's Divine Sac would be quite the asset.
http://talent.mmo-champion.com/?pala...1&version=9757
As for holy/ret, this spec would/will most likely be the choice for many hpally pvp'ers why? Because its more viable in 2v2, in the 2v2 bracket winning seems to be more based on burst and CC (atleast from what i've seen) - With a spec alot like the one below, mana will never be a problem and having Divine purpose and Repentance will both free up your partner and also help you keep either the off-target or their healer locked up. Only problem with this spec is you have limited oh-sh!t buttons and will take more damage in comparison to the holy/prot spec.
http://talent.mmo-champion.com/?paladin=503121503002120531300000000000000000000000000000000005230250223001320130000000&gl yph=071619040301&version=9757
These are my current thoughts, I've cut myself a bit short to keep discussion more open and variable. Do keep in mind these specs are just tossed together examples not set in stone or deeply thought out, I just wanted to give a general example for the thread. I am looking forward to an intelligent discussion and some interesting points. Thank You for your time.