Worldcarver VS Betrayer of Humanity

[funkymillah]

Pretty simple: Which one do you think is better in the following scenario:

http://www.wowhead.com/?item=45165 Worldcarver reduces crit to 32% and caps expertise.
http://www.wowhead.com/?item=40384 Betrayer of Humanity boosts the crit upto 35% unbuffed but leaves expertise at 16.

So basically 10 Expertise vs 3% Crit. What will you choose?

Edit: Might I add, atleast 90 attackpower unbuffed and the Str on the carver gains bonus from kings.

Rawr definately says Worldcarver, but I want some live opinions.

[bals]

you also gain 50+ ap with worldcarver + higher damage

and you check rawr with full raid buffs or not?

[Adamson]

Is this a joke?

Worldcarver is in every way better.

[Omican]

Worldcarver without a doubt.

[Tyneside]

My opinion is that you have to be joking. Worldcarver is clearly superior.

[Horn]

Is this a joke?

Worldcarver is in every way better.

[funkymillah]

My opinion is that you have to be joking. Worldcarver is clearly superior.

I was actually quite hesitant to lose the 3% crit but not anymore and yes Rawr definately puts it way up in the upgrade list (right below Voldrethar) actually.

[archform]

world

besides we crit alot already *im at like 24% in my crap gear and i crit alot*
try for world

[Fojos]

It's not just "10 expertise vs 3% crit". Worldcarver also gives more DPS. (10 more, it's a lot)

[Omen321]

ya sorry fail palladin's .. its a DK tanking weapon .. get in line IMO ( i already have mine )

[archform]

ya sorry fail palladin's .. its a DK tanking weapon .. get in line IMO ( i already have mine )

screenshot+ armory!!!!
damn Dks lol jk

[Omen321]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ng&n=%C3%93men im in th emiddle of 10man so im not SSing

[funkymillah]

world

besides we crit alot already *im at like 24% in my crap gear and i crit alot*
try for world

Well I have both. Equipping WC gave me an addition ~150 DPS overall even though I lost 3% crit. This is raidbuffed. Just tested on the dummies.

[SFJake]

As far as I know, higher DPS on your weapon has a huge impact on your DPS, since crusader strike, judgement, seal procs and divine storm scales from it.

That and more AP total = instant win, no question, no discussion.

[Undertaker]

You might as well aim for Earthshaper (Drops from 25 Yogg-Saron normal mode). With a Rawr setup I used you're going to be expertise capped + hit capped without Worldcarver. Though some of it might require hard mode loot.

If you dont have to spend your entire DKP to get Worldcarver, I guess it's worth using until you have the other items to fill out the expertise you lose from switching Worldcarver to Earthshaper.

[archform]

You might as well aim for Earthshaper (Drops from 25 Yogg-Saron normal mode). With a Rawr setup I used you're going to be expertise capped + hit capped without Worldcarver. Though some of it might require hard mode loot.

If you dont have to spend your entire DKP to get Worldcarver, I guess it's worth using until you have the other items to fill out the expertise you lose from switching Worldcarver to Earthshaper.

ive yet to get find a guild that uses DKP....

[Gzilia]

ive yet to get find a guild that uses DKP....

yet to get find ?

anyway - if you havent found a guild with dkp yet, I feel sorry for you.

[archform]

yet to get find ?

anyway - if you havent found a guild with dkp yet, I feel sorry for you.

why DKP sounds kinda annoying*never done it*

[Gzilia]

why DKP sounds kinda annoying*never done it*

Soo..

You never raided pre wotlk?
Or did everyone just /roll for laughters?
I can understand the hussle of DKP in naxx because well, its more work to register DKP than it is to clear it.

[archform]

Soo..

You never raided pre wotlk?
Or did everyone just /roll for laughters?
I can understand the hussle of DKP in naxx because well, its more work to register DKP than it is to clear it.

in vanilla and tbc i was going thru a alt phase
made many many many characters and deleted many also