Rate The Rogue Above You.

[panda911]

I do use a spreadsheet, and I also test stuff ingame. So far agi has trumped arP every time.
Your spreadsheet may say something, but if you test ingame you might get other results.

No. No. And. No.

What, did you test it on a test dummy? Testing is highly inaccurate in head to head trials because each trial will not be identical. Maybe you get stuck on an ice patch for too long on H anub with vanish down. Maybe you have to swap one more time than your last trial on H twins.

You cannot judge what is best purely based on your own subjective trials. If you could, there would be no need for a spreadsheet.

Now what you say is partially true, atleast for poisons. For fights where you are constantly running and changing targets, wound/wound is clearly superior, even though the spreadsheet will say wound/deadly. This is not the case with gems, where either you do the best DPS you can, or you don't. And you obviously don't.

edit: someone rate me so we can end this ridiculous conversation.

[Asuna]

I'm not going to enter the above theorycrafting contest.

As for Panda911... I'm not a pro but you could def use a new wep. And IDK exactly with your gear but I have more benefits using tier chest with heroic TOGC10 gloves. Really nice char btw

I'd just like comments and/or ratings about my rogue.

P.S I am aware of the terrible blue gem in my belt, I just never bothered buying a nightmare tear because they are overpriced.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...27thol&n=Isuna

[routsch]

Nice gear 7/10.
Aim for some ilvl258 stuff.

Drop rupture from ur rotation.
Glyphe Evis, Skill Evis
profit

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...Kargath&n=Nazz

go ahead

[scribbler]

Nice gear 7/10.
Aim for some ilvl258 stuff.

Drop rupture from ur rotation.
Glyphe Evis, Skill Evis
profit

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...Kargath&n=Nazz

go ahead

Frickin epix mate real niice
10/10 for sure

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ade&n=Scribbly
here ya go let the flaming commence

[Stybba]

I dont see how you could have possibly not understood what I wrote, but I AM at the softcap 735 WITH Mjolnirs (100% with procc) and I still see a dps loss as I said. And telling me that gemming agi would give me a dps increase makes in absolutely no definition of the word sense, sense.

Thanks you for the answers thou...

[panda911]

I dont see how you could have possibly not understood what I wrote, but I AM at the softcap 735 WITH Mjolnirs (100% with procc) and I still see a dps loss as I said. And telling me that gemming agi would give me a dps increase makes in absolutely no definition of the word sense, sense.

Thanks you for the answers thou...

Yeah do not listen to argonion, you need to stay gemmed ArP. I do not know why you see a DPS loss, but with your gear you are perfectly fine to gem for armor pen.

[Genericrogue]

Yeah do not listen to argonion, you need to stay gemmed ArP. I do not know why you see a DPS loss, but with your gear you are perfectly fine to gem for armor pen.

Solid. i envy your Death's Choice. i have terrible roll skills (we have multiple ppl dkp capped)


go ahead: http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...n=Genericrogue

[Noktus]

Im with Panda on the ArP debate, Argonian if you have mjolnirs and your not gemming ArP to soft cap of 735 then your a naughty naughty rogue. Its mathmatically proven that ArP is stronger than Agi. In my guild we have 2 rogues, me as an ArP whore combat rogue and a guy who normally plays mutilate but has a combat offspec with h&s spec - obviously he is gemmed AgI, when looking through our logs I am on some occasions up doing up to 25% more damage (note damage not DPS - after all its damage done that really matters). I dont have Mjolnirs so I am trying to gem to hard cap, currently im sitting at 76.xx% food buffed ArP.

Sorry didnt look you up generic, armoury dont work at work but needed to speak my peace.

If anyone armouries me im in my Anub 25 TotGC build and glyphs, normally the standard 15/51/5 ruptureless combat with SS, Killing spree and evis glyphs.

[n33b0wner3]

Im with Panda on the ArP debate, Argonian if you have mjolnirs and your not gemming ArP to soft cap of 735 then your a naughty naughty rogue. Its mathmatically proven that ArP is stronger than Agi. In my guild we have 2 rogues, me as an ArP whore combat rogue and a guy who normally plays mutilate but has a combat offspec with h&s spec - obviously he is gemmed AgI, when looking through our logs I am on some occasions up doing up to 25% more damage (note damage not DPS - after all its damage done that really matters). I dont have Mjolnirs so I am trying to gem to hard cap, currently im sitting at 76.xx% food buffed ArP.

Sorry didnt look you up generic, armoury dont work at work but needed to speak my peace.

If anyone armouries me im in my Anub 25 TotGC build and glyphs, normally the standard 15/51/5 ruptureless combat with SS, Killing spree and evis glyphs.

7/10

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ron&n=Daggeris

[Vonlego]

Are you daft? That rogue knows what he's doing. The only "error" that might be there is that he is using an agi/crit gem instead of more armor pen when armor pen is becoming so very juicy near the hard cap. He even uses his nightmare tear in the optimal slot!

On the other hand, you have no professions, are wearing a pvp trinket for dps (Perhaps you were pvping in zero resil and no chain, also a negative anyways), have SIX incorrect enchants (including no hodir rep), you have 0/3 master poisoner (meaning it is mathematically impossible for you to dps well), and aren't even using a mutilate glyph!

Your pvp spec leaves room for question, and you are using terrible glyphs.

0/10 because if this isn't a zero, I don't know what is.

PS: Your meta isn't active.

I'm not interested in an armory rating, next guy in line find some poor rogue that got skipped and help them out if you would be so kind.

[panda911]

Solid. i envy your Death's Choice. i have terrible roll skills (we have multiple ppl dkp capped)


go ahead: http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...n=Genericrogue

Genericrogue: Good professions. Thats pretty much all I can say, you are in your pvp gear.

[Iacom]

Rather nice gear, but I thought ArP was nerfed? 9.5/10
http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...erhorn&n=Iacom

[panda911]

Rather nice gear, but I thought ArP was nerfed? 9.5/10
http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...erhorn&n=Iacom

Rather nice gear, but I thought mutilate was nerfed... >.>

ArP was nerfed, but it is still BiS for combat rogues.

You have way too much hit, and not enough expertise. You have blue gems. You have WAY too much armor pen for mutilate to be any good, you should find a good slow mainhand and go combat. Bad shoulder enchant. Bad cloak enchant. Do you even try to be the best you can?

6/10. Blue gems just show you don't care.

edit: don't rate me, iv'e been rated enough.

[Tremelizzer]

You have way too much hit, and not enough expertise.

Blame itemisation. I am 11% overhitcapped too and there's no way I can reduce it.

[Supersmurfen]

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...n=Supersmurfen

[Iacom]

Rather nice gear, but I thought mutilate was nerfed... >.>

ArP was nerfed, but it is still BiS for combat rogues.

You have way too much hit, and not enough expertise. You have blue gems. You have WAY too much armor pen for mutilate to be any good, you should find a good slow mainhand and go combat. Bad shoulder enchant. Bad cloak enchant. Do you even try to be the best you can?

6/10. Blue gems just show you don't care.

edit: don't rate me, iv'e been rated enough.

I has bad luck on the Hellscream Slicer. Never drops. Otherwise, I would go combat since I don't have another decent main hand.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...n=Supersmurfen

And PvP gear. Gtfo.

[Deleted]

Above me there is no any rogue to rate =) so look below and start flame =)

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...81%D0%BF%D0%B1

[flounda]

your gear is solid but you should have 3 points in imp evis and 2 in ruthlessness

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Nether&n=Omago

and yes i know my trinkets suck

[Voij]

your gear is solid but you should have 3 points in imp evis and 2 in ruthlessness

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Nether&n=Omago

and yes i know my trinkets suck

Change gems and enchant in/on chest, put nightmare tear in your belt or pants.
Upgrade gem in gloves, get new enchant for feet, put orange gem in them.
Same goes for Ring.
Pretty much overcapped on expertise, and I'm not quite sure whether it's actually worth it for you to spec into Evis yet. [Oh well, ToC is favoring Evis a lot though. *shrug*]



Here's me, just got the Banner today so I was finally able to drop Grim Toll:
http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...r=Ysera&n=Voij

[Rogue]

Change gems and enchant in/on chest, put nightmare tear in your belt or pants.
Upgrade gem in gloves, get new enchant for feet, put orange gem in them.
Same goes for Ring.
Pretty much overcapped on expertise, and I'm not quite sure whether it's actually worth it for you to spec into Evis yet. [Oh well, ToC is favoring Evis a lot though. *shrug*]



Here's me, just got the Banner today so I was finally able to drop Grim Toll:
http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...r=Ysera&n=Voij

Everything checks out, pretty jealous of the mainhand.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Blade&n=Ryuker