Crit and haste aren't terrible, relative to mastery, and the resil is a huge loss overall. The only reason we ever got away with using pvp gear in t11 was because of, before the nerf, you got massive strength bonuses from the set bonuses, and after that, the gloves still gave you 5% cs damage. However, cloaks and rings and the like should only be used if you have like some blue shit or something, otherwise the loss of stats overall usually isn't worth it.