I've made this post in another topic, but i think it's complex enough to be a topic itself.
One of the main choices of healer is trinket choosing. i've seen a lot of pallys with +128int trinket, a lot with Darkmoon card. to be honest, i've rarely seen two pallys with similar trinket setup, so i decided to make trinket comparsion theme. currently now i'll only copy/paste my previous post because there are 22.30pm now (i live GMT+3), but i'll try to add other healing trinkets in future. i'll be glad if you'll help me with trinket names, because i can miss some.
18.02.2010: added Ephemeral Snowflake, modified Silver of Pure Ice rating.
program, used for calculations:
http://www.mmo-champion.com/threads/...ct-Calculator/
the new build is available, now you can save results as a screenshot.
----------------
i'm calculating assuming you have BoK, divine intellect 5/5, BE racial, Replenish 100% uptime, FoL casting time 1.1, HL casting time 1.25, 120sec Plea cd.
initial mana pool is converted to mp5 by formula mp5=mana/7/60*5 (assuming 7 minutes average fight time).
Tears (84 int)
+50mp5 with proc
total mp5: 105 to 112
Alga-10 (111 int)
proc:
(it was buffed in 3.2 up to 75mp5 per stack)
if you manage to take 20th stack to the end of duration, it will regen to you:
75/5=15 mana each second per stack,(15+15*20)/2*20= 3150 mana each 120s=131.25mp5
healing through Beacon counts as second spell. its nearby +750 (~3900) mana per use, +30 mp5. ( http://www.mmo-champion.com/class-pa...55/#msg1896655 )
total mp5:234 to 214
Card one(90int):
assuming you use Plea on procs:
300*15*0.25=+1125 mana every plea (46 mp5 with plea cd 2 min)
total mp5: 105 to 112
Badge one(128int):
total mp5: 84.6 to 94.6
the triumph badge one is worst one in mp5 counting. if you think that +700sp (~+6% healing through plea, since it cuts half the bonus - search for calculating in this thread) worths 20mp5 loss comparing even to Tears, take it. but personally i think that it doesn't worth.
card/Tears are nearby equal, but if you missed with using plea when Card procced (maybe tank was dying so you was not able to place -50% healing on yourself) then it is trash.
Sollace o the Fallen/defeated:
124mp5+150sp (144mp5 + 168 sp heroic version)
Silver of pure Ice heroic
1830/120 * 5 = 76.25 mp5 (1min CD was a typo )
Purified Lunar Dust:
3 ticks for 305 mana = 915 mana
915mana/55 *5 = 83 mp5 /// i assuming 55sec cd because of 45 sec internal cd and 0.1 chance to proc (procced nearby on 10 cast, if you have 1sec FoL cast time it's +10 seconds to internal cd
finally, the priority list:
counting only mp5 (read it if you think that sp, even in 100+ amounts, is not worth 10-20 mp5):
Alga10->solace258>solace245>Tears~>card~>ToR~>PLD~>silver of pure ice (hc)
counting sp&mp5 (do not read it if you think that sp, even in 100+ amounts, is not worth 10-20 mp5):
Solace258>alga-10~>solace245>PLD~>tears~~silver of pure ice (hc)~>card~>ToR~>silver of pure ice
by combinations:
Solace258+Meteorite shard >Solace x2 >solace[245 or 258]+tears~>solace[245 or 258]+silver of pure ice (hc)~>solace[245 or 258]+Talisman.
i've made priority only to few popular trinkets, so there are others (they all are worse than Tears of Vanquished, but can be compared to Talisman of Resurgence)
Pandora's Plea:
71.3 to 79.3 mp5, 26 sp. proc is uncontrollable, so you can't manage to use plea with it - so it is pure overhealing.
Bauble of true blood: 86/76 mp5, proc is useful only in PvP
Show of Faith: 66mp5 &140sp
Silver of pure Ice normal
1625/120 * 5 = 67 mp5 +158sp
Althor's Abacus: 180/200sp, zero proc
Binding stone / light, Energy Syphon, Living Ice crystals : all average 60 mp5 with nearby-zero procs.
Purified/shiny shard of the scales:
85/96 mp5. this trinket is pretty interesting, because in full-set it gives you:
95mp5, 600health per 5 seconds, 250sp and useless proc, which will be overhealing. it is good, but two good trinkets would be better.
Ephemeral Snowflake:
due to nerf it has hidden 0.4sec cooldown. this cooldown means that it doesn't proc off Beaconed spell (since spell+his beaconed copy are 'casted' faster than 0.4secs), it doesn't proc off GoHoL (since these 5 heals are in the same time as main HL). also it doesn't proc off JoL, off FoL ticks or off HS ticks (with t8). so, in ideal situation when you are casting 1 cast each second (flash spamming or HL spamming with bloodlust) this trinket will give you 11*5=55 mp5.
overall: 35-55mp5+pocket bloodlust. this is even worse than Spark of Life from Sjonnir (HoS).