Tankadin Trinket Question

[grymgroeth]

DPS that can't beat the tank have no room to complain about anything unless the tank is legitimately bad. As long as you're holding aggro and staying alive (should be simple anywhere but prenerf HHoR) you have more than enough hp at 33k for heroics, naxx or starting Uld10.

[balloonknot]

for heroics it HP is pretty meaningless (except the new ones will be easier in EH gear)

my heroic set i'm at ~33k unbuffed, hit capped, exp soft capped, over the SoR BV soft cap. Those are the stats you should maximize for speeding through heroics and you should attempt to maintain something like 3.5k dps for the run using SoV, higher if you spec into SoComm and glyph for hammer.

its relatively difficult for dps to out dps a paly tank is such a setup and the healing required is minimal at best, high physical damage heroics you can often with without a healer as long as you have someone who can top people off between pulls.

For raid tanking you should be stacking effective health stam and to a lesser extent armor. Anyone that tells you avoidance is the measure of a raid tank in ToC or ICC doesn't understand the mechanics of the currently available encounters in either instance. You most certainly should keep any and all gear you come across as if you don't you will regret it when blizz drops some encounter where avoidance matters again.