Originally Posted by
praide
Seriously, I remember all the QQ about Gearscore and it feels like ilvl has arrived relatively unscathed. With that aside, I'm going to admit now that I liked gearscore and I like ilvl but they both miss the point of what we, as raid organizers, really need; we need a way to assess the individual ability of our raid and some way to sum that up to a raid view to understand if we have the heal/dps/avoidance/cc/interrupts to perform.
In my mind, Blizzard really missed the boat with ilvl. They took gearscore which was helpful but only marginally so, and they replicated it.
Instead of gearscore, what I'd really like to know is how well the individual did the last time they faced this boss. In absence of that data I'd like to know how well that individual did in heroics. Maybe average dps, number of wipes, number of completed instances, cc, etc. Maybe even a user ranking system with user comments. Is there a mod out there that does that?