Same here 12/12. I've never seen any plate or tokens drop off of Nef or Cho'gall. That mail belt seems to drop off of Cho everytime though. We've beaten Magmaw 10 times now. I've seen the lava spine drop EVERY time. I'm MS tank and Duel Spec fury. I went SMF because I've never seen a epic two hander drop. However we do get ALOT of caster trinkets which I suppose is good for the healers.