Originally Posted by
reploid
So out of this 114 page discussion, this is what I got to say:
1) I hope they don´t add any new classes. They´ve got 12 to fix. 36 if you count every spec. Demon Hunter´s still only have 2 specs.
2) If they do add a new class, which I doubt they will, it wont be tinkers. Tinkers have no relevance to the main theme of the next expansion whatsoever, and this would be the first time a class was added without any relevance to the main storyline (wrath=dks, mop=monks, legion=dhs). Last time they added a controversial class it was monks, and it remains as the least played class. There´s a lot of regret there. I am sure they would take monks back if they could. It was an unnecessary overlap in melee that even caused dhs to have so little to explore and ended up with 2 specs to begin with.
3) Sylvanas is at the cover of Blizzcon, most likely indicating a death themed expansion.
4) Mechagon was its own thing. A contained quest hub and dungeon that did not have any relevance to BFA. A nod to players that enjoy that sort of thing, that even produced an allied race in the form of the diaper gnomes.
5) It could have been more believable or probable if mekkatorque wasn´t ressurrected during the diaper gnome AR questline and they were added as a race on the pre-patch for the new expansion. That whole thing starting in 8.1 with him being frozen and finishing in 8.3 with the diaper gnomes allied race pretty much gives it a beggining, middle and end. No need to revisit it whatsoever.
IF tinkers were added as a class at this point while within a death theme expansion (or void themed), it would leave a lot of people scratching their heads. It wouldnt make any sense, there´s absolutely NO buildup.
Entertaining the idea, I would be personally not the least interested on them. Hell, with all 12 classes as I currently have, I´m constantly considering deleting a couple that I dont like, but decided to keep them just to see what blizzard will do to classes next exp pack. Not to mention a technology based class detracts from the magic fantasy theme of everything else. I wouldnt stop playing the game over it, but cant say I would enjoy it
My 2 cents.