Who will be your 4 toons?

[Xe4ro]

Well my main will be my druid as every expansion. Then I will need my herb alt which this time will probably be my shaman, likely resto. Then i was planning on leveling a tank alt, my warr. Not sure what after that as I do have every class but I will wait on how fast the level experience is and how time consuming raiding/m+ will be.

So in short.

Druid - Balance
Shaman - Resto
Warrior - Prot
…?

[SynDethroc]

Undead Assassination Rogue (Main) - Necrolord
Nightborne Affliction Warlock - Night Fae
Worgen Survival Hunter - Venthyr
Undead Unholy DK - Necrolord
Bastion is so bland and boring I probably won't have a character join until I'm down to leveling my last few alts

[d00dles]

My main will either be:

Venthyr - Zandalari arms warrior
-- I don't really care about the vampire theme and I don't think the teleport will turn out to be as OP as people claim it to be. I just want that sweet execute animation.
-- Bonus points that the Zandalari look great in plate gear and don't have some wack dual wield animations like some other races (looking at you, orcs)

or

Necrolord - Blood elf arcane mage
-- I wanna rock that Necrolord look. Yes baby please!!!
-- The cloth mog looks great on a blood elf.
-- I'm a bit worried that the zone/campaign might be wack thou.

Alts:

(I'm still trying to decide these...)

Night Fae - Blood elf mm hunter or ww monk
-- The monk seemed really fun as Night Fae from what I have seen. But there are some changes coming up. This is more of a wait and see situation for me.

Kyrian - Undead shadow priest or Troll elemental shaman
-- I know exactly what to expect from Elemental shaman pvp and that's exactly what's holding me back.

I also plan on leveling a DK at some point. It just seems fitting for the expansion.

[Zeph76]

Venthyr Night Elf Rogue
Necrolord Human Death Knight
Kyrian Draenei Paladin
Night Fae Night Elf Demon Hunter
(still undecided about my Dark Iron Warrior)

[Rusken]

Currently I'm thinking DK - Night Fae, Shaman - Venthyr, Warlock - Necrolord. May or may not do a 4th later down the track when I get bored with those 3, which would probably be a Monk, Mage, Warrior or Rogue none of which I have any idea of which Covenant to choose.

[Hero2Zer0]

Pally for bastion, Warrior and Druid for Ard, Hunter for Venth, DK for Mal.

Did you do any research or are you going for aesthetics? I had similar thoughts based solely on aesthetics.

[damonskye]

Arcane Mage (Night Fae) (this is my main)
BM Hunter or WW Monk (Venthyr)
Fury Warrior (Kyrian)
Assassin Rogue or Demo Warlock (Necrolord)

[Throghar85]

Male Dwarf Holy Paladin for Kyrian (main since 2007)
Male Dwarf Ench Shaman for Night Fae (main alt since 2011)
Female Gnome Destro Lock for Necrolords (since 2009)
Female Gnome Assasination Rogue for Venthyr (since 2008)

Next I will play DK Blood for tanking, and maybe if I will have time some dwarf windwalker monk and dwarf prot warrior.

[RadmaKanow]

Err... don't even know what covenants are there, will learn on the go.

<taking a peek into other replys the get any meaning>

Main - Feral Druid - Night Fae.
Obviously

BM Hunter - haven't decided yet

Frost Death Knight - Necrolord

Retribution Paladin - Kyrian...

You see where it's going. I pick my covenants by RP value and I don't care about "which is better, hurr durr" BS. I don't ride, Iplay for the enojyment of the story and class. If it suits my class, it gets picked. I have so many alts so I can make any combination if primary choice won't satisfy me.

[Whitedragon]

Did you do any research or are you going for aesthetics? I had similar thoughts based solely on aesthetics.

Nearly fully on aesthetic, the only ability I really know of is the paladin one from bastion and I love the idea of chucking a volley of shields out, but he was going to be bastion regardless. I never have let FotM dictate what or how I play, from classic to now if I think it's cool or fun i'll take that over the 1-3% boost.

[Volcker]

Like many on here, I'll be choosing covenants base on what would fit my characters thematically. My first four will likely be:

Protection Paladin (Main) -> Kyrian
Windwalker/Mistweaver Monk -> Night Fae
Assassination Rogue -> Venthyr
Frost Death Knight -> Necrolords

[Kyphael]

Revendreth - Worgen Blood Death Knight
Maldraxxus - Void Elf Destruction Warlock
Bastion - Blood Elf Protection Paladin
Ardenweald - Nightborne Beastmaster Hunter

[Florena]

Sin rogue
Prot pally
Mage (changes specs often)
Outlaw rogue (yes I have two rogues, mostly for RP reasons.)

Assuming that I get into Shadowlands much in the first place.

[AngerFork]

I always go with healers for my main/alts to begin with, and Shadowlands will be no different. Currently, here's how I see them laying out for me.

Ardenweald - Night Elf Druid (Resto/Balance)
Bastion - Lightforged Paladin (Holy/Ret)
Revendreth - Dwarf Monk (Mist/WW)
Maldraxxus - Void Elf Priest (Holy/Shadow)

I also have a Shaman waiting in the wings to replace one of these if I opt to bring in a shaman instead.

[Nize]

Shooting for thematic, as much as I'll hate not being best optimized.

Human Death Knight - Necrolord
Night Elf Hunter - Night Fae
Void Elf Warlock - Venthyr
Human Paladin or Warrior (still deciding) - Kyrian

[Snowfunk]

My Ret main - Venthyr or Kyrian, haven't decided yet.

I always go all in on my main, at the start, so alts will come later.
But my second, will be my Warrior, picking the covenant I didn't go with on my Paladin.

After that, I'm honestly not sure. Usually my Mage would be next in line, but I'm kind of temped to go with my DK.
Simply to secure another plate set for transmogging, since they will most likely lift the restrictions, in the following expansion.

[Zuben]

I play one toon 95% of the time, the other 5% going to my Alliance alt mostly just to see content on that side of the fence, though the Covenant storylines feel like something I want to experience. If I can be bothered it'll probably go like this:

Venthyr: My main, blood elf mage.
Night Fae: My Alliance main ("prime alt"), dwarf shaman.
Necrolords: My former main, orc warrior.
Kyrian: This one is still TBD, but possibly blood elf paladin. Or hell, maybe I'll finally give an allied race a shot. I'd get to see some missed classhall content in Legion that way too.

Decided to pay no mind to Covenant abilities, these are strictly thematic choices.

[Gestopft]

I'll probably just do something similar to what I usually do. I'll start with my hunter, then warrior, warlock, shaman or maybe DH. I don't even know what covenants I will be yet, but between my 12 (or more) toons, I'll eventually have them all covered.

[Benitora]

Mistweaver Monk, Arcane mage, Subtlety Rogue and Blood Death knight.

Those are at least the ones I'll attempt to work into the four different covenants. My main is still undecided between Mistweaver monk and Subtlety Rogue.

[Jastall]

So far, I'll have a Necrolord Fury Warrior, Venthyr Blood/UH DK,Night Fae Holy/Ret Paladin, and Kyrian Havoc Demon Hunter. That's the initial plan at least, if the Venthyr are just too strong for DPS Warriors I'll go there and have my DK sacrificed to Necrolords considering its ability is quite clearly dogshit for PvE. Don't really care about optimizing my alts.