That depends on how they're presented, really. I just hope they don't fall into the same category as gnomes from WoW in that they have a few scraps of intriguing lore but are overshadowed by gimmicky jokes. I suspect that is why some people are concerned and tentative about the Asura race. Though the developers of GW2 seem pretty competent and have seemingly managed to present the Asura very well.
In case you aren't familiar with the Asura lore,
They're all basically arrogant dicks, and are a lot less "happy" of a race than the gnomes. If an asura smiles at you, it's more like a serial killer grin than a small child's.History
The asura were originally a subterranean race, adapted for their cavernous homes deep beneath the surface. They had evolved excellent senses—their long ears and wide, luminous eyes missed nothing—and sharp teeth for an omnivorous diet. They were uniformly brilliant as a people, analyzing, solving, and utilizing the intricate nature of magic itself. Using this power, they spread throughout the Depths of Tyria, linking distant locations with their asura gates and building great underground citadels on places of incredible arcane power.
To their horrified surprise, one of those spots proved to be the home of an Elder Dragon champion. The Great Destroyer, a legendary figure among the dwarves, stirred. Using the very portals the asura had built over its lair, it spread its minions throughout the underground, destroying the bulk of asuran civilization and forcing the survivors into the dangerous and unknown surface world.
The asura were nothing if not resourceful. Armed with what knowledge they had salvaged, and blessed with a surplus of inventive geniuses, they soon dominated the region of the Tarnished Coast. Their golems pushed back the jungles. Their levitation spells set their towns above the dangerous surroundings. And their reconfigured gates allowed them to cross a new world filled with dangerous and alien races. Ingenuity and organization gave them the advantage necessary to prevail.
Asuran society is organized around krewes—loose-knit research organizations, usually commanded by one particularly brilliant member. Highly motivated and competitive, these krewes codify and advance the magical brilliance of the people as they seek to recover lost knowledge, create new fields of study, and unlock the answers in the universal philosophy they call the Eternal Alchemy.
A race of magical innovators and mystical inventors, the asura have done nothing but prosper in the centuries since they arrived on the surface. Useful races have been turned into allies while less useful ones have been controlled and contained. New horizons have been opened, and old knowledge has been recovered.
Last edited by Larynx; 2012-05-25 at 03:31 AM.
They definitely are shaping up to be. Like I said, the book is really creating a personality for all the races.
Well, except for humans. IMO ArenaNet should have actually gone all out and just wiped Cantha and Elona off the map, so that humanity actually is a dying race. And then have their story heavily revolve around the gods forsaking them, but having the devotion and faith to press on.
No thank you. If you ask me, the worst way to add personality to a race is to wipe out two different cultures of it. Besides, the humans in Tyria are already a struggling race, and the events occurring in Elona and Cantha aren't all too great either.
The Asura look great, and I'm really liking the scenery and architecture.
The current situation for humans in Cantha is just fine though? They're just isolationists with a oppressive ruler, but as a race they're not threatened. Elona I'm not 100% sure of. It's ruled, again, by an oppressive leader who also happens to be an extremely powerful undead lich, and is being assaulted by minions of Zhaitan and Kralkatorrik. So the situation is grim, but I don't know how grim.
With Tyria, really barely has changed since GW1. They're no more dying out now then they were then.
I just don't really understand it. What I've heard and what I actually see contradict each other.
I'd hardly say that humans are growing, but they're still better off than all the other races, with the exception of the charr.
edit: Now that I think of it, the asura are probably thriving as well, even if they haven't really expanded their territory much.
Last edited by Larynx; 2012-05-25 at 04:08 AM.
I think Cantha is very strongly controlled. Very much like a total dictatorship, which can't be conducive to growth. It's prob not being ravaged but can't say it's growing. It may just be stagnant.
Elona is...probably also more stagnant. But that Joko really is an evil monster and holds elona in a a grip of undead terror. U certainly can't say it's growing either.
Still....there's certainly more humans than any other race. They're not on the utter brink of disaster and extinction by any means, but they're not doing as well as they were 300 years ago.
Zhaitan is in direct conflict with Palawa Joko, in addition to Kralkatorrik.
He also is blocking all the sea routes out of Tyria.
---------- Post added 2012-05-25 at 12:17 AM ----------
When their personality is this "dying race" archetype, yes you do kind of need to follow it...
---------- Post added 2012-05-25 at 12:22 AM ----------
I'm still confused by the humans. Even the human page on the website has that general tone, with the exception of this one sentence:
So suddenly now they're doing just fine?Although surrounded by challenges and confronted by threats within and without, the race survives and thrives in a world that becomes more deadly by the day.
Last edited by Larynx; 2012-05-25 at 04:22 AM.
Ok......maybe it's better to say Tyrians are a dying race?
But my point was they're no more dying than they were 250 years ago.
---------- Post added 2012-05-25 at 12:29 AM ----------
Um, okay. Were you adding to my post or arguing against it? o_O
Cantha being cut off from Tyria is irrelevant since Cantha is an isolationist state.