Do both of you really need to attack each other personally over this? I don't feel like that's productive.
I took a look at my WoL and I saw that I'm getting a lot of hits of Eminence--more than once per damaging event, but it's definitely not 50% of the auto-attack hit to everyone within range of me. My log looks quite strange actually. The first thing I noticed is that Eminence healing is affected by the +20% healing of Wise Serpent Stance, which means you're really doing 120% of your damage as healing. The second thing I noticed is that SZ Eminence is distributed very oddly. It's going out in small packets of about 2000 heals, but who it targets appears rather random, since it is hitting the same person multiple times. Although perhaps this is just a log-ordering issue?
(This is excluding statue heals... add 'and spell="Eminence (Statue)"' after the 'spell="Eminence"' to see statue heals)
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/a...ce%22%29%29%29