At the end of Act 1 does it make a huge difference. If you kill the guy or not. I saw no reason to kill him that wasn't the orders. He gave himself up and I gained affection. Here's the link to that

Now I'm at the start of ACT 2. I have to pick one of them as I am promoted as captain. I pick Throne because she seems have no sen sense attitude and knows what she's doing. Does it matter one way or another in a huge way without spoiling anything out of these choices. I'm starting on Act 2. I need level up some.