I'm glad someone used the term 'spreadsheet-approved'. I think GC is a great dev, but his weakness to me is he is a numbers man and finds it hard to empathise with things that are more subjective. He said once he doesn't care much about transmog, yet lots of peoples love making their characters look badass. I think the same principle applies to spells, lots of players love cool spells, but GC only sees them in terms of how the spell functions in raids. I think its a fair criticism of him.