So, I recently fell back in love with my hunter and remembered Gara. I rolled down to the starting spot in Shadowmoon, but I just get the generic dialog box... no scratching the ears or showing Gara the berries for me. I even had the berries in my pack when I talked to it... nothing. This toon has never been anything but BM, so I have no idea what i'm doing wrong. I tried dropping the berries and obtaining "fresh" ones, but no change. Logged off and back on... nothing.
Not sure what to do next... I suppose I could try to move on to the next step and see if the Effigy parts drop for me. Or is this quest bugged after the recent patch. Any ideas?