Er, I hadn't replied to you on that exchange because it was literally a long weekend here and I literally just caught up with the goings on in the thread.
If you want to carry on that exchange, then sure, I can merely brush off what you listed as being the 30% talk about the show while 70% is still talking about stuff around the show. Just like it happens to be in most other threads here.
And most of what you posted consists of how many posts overall in the 10 pages you sifted through? It's usually a few posts talking about it, then the conversation ends quick.
And Nielsen ratings discussions are only partially talking about the show, considering much of the back and forth in that was about how the system works or is flawed or how people are using the data incorrectly, more than actually applying it to the show. But hey, if you think that's all related to the show, then I'll agree to disagree with you on this front. Just like I don't think the Rey/Carol Danvers thing is really related to the show at all either. I disagree that it is relevant to discussing the show, because I think the show's problems are unique to itself.
Hell, this exchange right now is not about the show either. But I'm sure we will also disagree on this point.
-edit-
And again, I made that original comment because like 10 different people all jumped into that same topic, throwing out comments that weren't relevant to the show at all. And it all sourced to one throwaway bad example that was intentionally opinionated for the sake of externalizing the argument. This is even confirmed a couple posts below. The whole ordeal is about diversity criticisms, not anything specific to RoP.