Musicbox or Bloodshaper

[Liarparadox]

Sim is telling me that 385 Musicbox and 390 Bloodshaper are virtually tied for dps. Bloodshapper pulling out very slightly ahead in 3+ targets (by around 0.5% at most).

Anything to consider in picking which one to use? Like any known simcraft issue with these trinkets? Maybe one isn't modelled as well?

Edit: Or anything about the way the proc functions in a real setting that's worth considering that sim doesn't already take into account?

I was sorta surprised or disappointed that the Bloodshaper wasn't a clear upgrade on the sim. But any words of wisdom from people who actually have insight would be great.

Please don't guess, I don't want feelingcraft or mystic-craft or iwannafeelimportantsoiwillgivesomeadviceeventhoughihavenocluewhatiamtalkingabout-craft


If it happens to matter: It's for Affliction.

[nToxik]

If they sim the same, it doesn't matter much. I'm not sure if Musicbox was fixed (or if it is normal) but I believe it used to aggro random mobs that are close to you. If it is still working this way then maybe not as good for M+?

[MysticsDK]

Music box for ST. Very little between the two tbh. Simmed it on my loc and wished I hadn't. gz on the drops btw.

[Greyarea]

It would also depend on your second trinket you use as well. there could be a case where you use them both and replace your current 2nd trinket

[Liarparadox]

Ah, yeah, but it's Fuse 380, which has far more utility in real world setting than either one of those. So I don't think i'd want to get rid of the capacity to inject some nice haste like that.

But worth keeping in mind i suppose; I'll keep them in all in bags and have to test stuff out I think