Originally Posted by
kendro1200
The druids also slept in shifts, not all of them were sleeping all of the time either.
Let's entirely forget the War of the Satyr and the War of the Shifting Sands. Two wars that put everything except maybe the third war and the most recent Legion invasion to shame on size and scope of life lost and stakes.
War of the Satyr would have brought back the Burning Legion before Silvermoon was even up and a city, before the Earthen reawoke as dwarves, the humans started setting up kingdoms or the Trolls to be able to recover from the Sundering.
The War of the Shifting Sands was so brutal that even the Dragonflights when hiding from Deathwing decided that the situation was dire enough that they had to step in or all else was lost.
The Sin'Dorei have two major things in common with the Shal'dorei.
One: Both people hid in magical cities with arcane wards to hide their activity and shields to protect them from physical threats and literally ignored everything going on in the world until their cities were burning.
Two: Both people are super butt hurt about a majority of the Kaldorei turning their back on obsessive arcane studies and claim to be victims of the Kaldorei banning dangerous studies into arcane magic.
This latter one is the most important because the circumstances that befell both the Sin'Dorei and Shal'dorei are directly related to their own choices after the Sundering. The Quel'dorei chose exile to go and hide their arcane practices from greater Kal'dorei society after their revolt in Ashenvale went sideways. They then built another city on sacred troll lands, built up their arcane usage, then went and trained humans to use arcane magic but forgot to tell humans that using arcane magic without special wards will draw the attention of the Burning Legion and lead to another invasion. The humans had to learn the lesson of demons invading and killing them entirely on their own, and instead of practicing magic safely they chose to make a demigod mage to fight demons. The Quel'dorei knew this was going on and did nothing. The Quel'dorei knew about the events of the first and second war and did nothing until an orc army was burning Quel'thalas down. When the undead plague was ravaging Lordearon the Quel'dorei did nothing again. The Quel'dorei only saw the undead plague as an issue when Arthas starting destroying their gates.
Note: the Kaldorei knew about the first and second war, but they had their own problems to worry about at the time, and they were also duty bound to protect the World Tree. The Kaldorei were literally sending agents across the world keeping an eye on it and trying to keep targets they saw most dangerous to the safety of Azeroth and then either killing them or locking them up in the Warden's Vault.
The Shal'dorei were even worse than the Quel'dorei/Sin'dorei. They actively chose to ignore the entire world. They knew everything was going to hell and that the fate of the world was in the balance and they chose to put up a shield and then ignore the world. For ten thousand years they decided ignoring the world was better than interacting with it, and they also knew that their method of ignoring the world was slowly killing them. Then, when refaced with the consequences of their actions from 10,000 years ago they caved and chose to ignore the problem again. This is very important the Shal'dorei in Suramar aren't direct descendants of the ancient Highborne society, they are the Highborne society from 10,000 years ago. Apart from children that grew up, most of the adults are literally the people that were alive and chose to work with Azshara and bringing the Legion to Azeroth, only to get cold feet part way through and then create a shield and ignore everyone.
The only breed of elves that have showed any capability of learning from their mistakes has been the Kaldorei. They make a mistake, it usually brings them to the edge of extinction, but they learn and change. The arcane obsessed offshoots of the Kaldorei have never learned and constantly make it the rest of the world's problem with their choices.
So no, the Shal'dorei and Sin'dorei did not make the correct choice when they joined the Horde, because each time they did so in an attempt to gain or maintain power and not accept responsibility for their past mistakes.
The Sin'dorei rejoining the Alliance would mean they would have to accept that they've made a lot of bad choices since they left Ashenvale.
The Shal'dorei joining the Alliance would mean they would have to reconcile with the Kaldorei, who also made it possible from the Shal'dorei to still exist without the Eye of Amun'thul powering the Nightwell.
Anyways that is my thoughts and rants on the matter. Lady Liadrin isn't savage, she is an intolerably proud and willfully ignorant individual who really should have been best friends with Garrosh, and probably has tea with Sylvanas every other afternoon if she honestly thinks that there is anything right or justified with the Horde's current state. Liadrin is just another case and point that the Light is not inherently good nor does someone using it make them virtuous. I could not see Liadrin ever being welcome in any temple of the Light, be it Light's Hope or the Netherlight Temple after a comment like that, as it does directly conflict with how other practices of the Light believe one should act.
edit:
Also he wasn't protecting it the whole time, it's been repeated over and over again. The Druids would protect the Emerald Dream in shifts and when they were not protecting the Emerald Dream they protected the physical world.
You know all of those world trees around Azeroth? Fandral Staghelm planted those to take care of the saronite infestation. Remember saronite, the blood of Yog'saron? One of Yog'saron's escape attempts was to just leak his blood out across the planet and corrupt everything, and he almost succeeded. While Malfurion was in his first Emerald Dream shift, Fandral took care of that problem by planting additional world trees, which stopped the spread of saronite. Malfurion was upset when he woke up later and found out that Fandral had done that because it should have been discussed in detail before executed.
The druids basically took over the jobs of the Red and Green dragonflights between the War of the Ancients and the Third War. The rest of the Night Elf society took over the job of the Black Dragonflight, and protected the world from major external threats.
If you really want to look at a people that saw the world falling apart and did nothing, look at the Zandalari. They did not participate in the War of the Ancients, they did not help anyone or do anything until the return of Hakkar. For all intents and purposes the Zandalari slept for 10,000 years.