Originally Posted by
ravenmoon
Elves were popular in every expansion, and the 2 based on them have been two of the most popular of the lot. Sales certainly resurged when the night elves were shown in Legion to have much more to them than the treehugger wood elf trope players assumed they were
It's the combination. No one has done star elves, nor combined wood elf and dark elf like the night elves do. Yes dark elf has been arcane but, evil and one dimensional.
Night elves on the other hand have arcane, nature, Elune and the stars, with the fel playing a role. Mostly lawful good or chaotic good, with a star and moon focus, they are utterly unique.
I've never seen druids who also call on the stars and moon, nor dark elves that are actually thoroughly good or any elf with a star and moon fascination...supimultaneously having grand cities - like the night elves halve AND grand forests.
I've also never seen dark elves with a proper outdoor night stars moon theme, nor wood elves with the sort of waking forest up thing or combining the two like pre addiction pre sundering night elves did or the post long vigil night elves are doing combining strong arcane with strong nature.
As for Thalassian elves, the whole void thing is entirely unìque, a dark maddening magic wielded without corruption by Thalassian elves. Blood elves as high elves who aren't perfectly good but have a rebel bad boy vibe to them at the same time as an arrogant rich boy tone. Adding a sun focus to them, then an undead elf aspect and their fel elf is rather different from the Illidari too. High elves that gave in to evil demons like Kael'thas does.
Warcraft elves have at leas 6 varieties each between Night Elf kind and Thalassian elf kind.
Night Elf
Night elf: Kaldorei - shal'dorei, cenarian, illidari, Ravencrest undead and Farondis ghost , as well as highborne mage, Druid and Moon priestess each having a distinct feel to them each of them, whether it is the sub race of night elf or the discipline.
You have the kaldorei as the star elf fusion of dark elf and forest elf, the shal'dorei retaining the dark elf arcane pre sundering era version of them, the cenarion half night elf representing the forest elf version, the Illidari night elf as the anti hero demon elf that is chaotic good, the Ravencrest undead who turn out to be decent undead when you free their leader and the quasi living highborne ghosts who are ghost form of the pre addiction pre sundering night elven nobility before they got corrupt.
Now examine the class distinctions and how highborne is so different from druid and in turn so different from moon priest and in turn so different from demon hunter with their devotions to the arcane, nature, Elune and fel, yet they have the common theme of desiring to do good and save, even the fel demonized version. In a properly constructed night world version of all the themes that exist in the day elf with its own variation.
You find this detail and variation in any other fantasy for dark elves or elves for that matter?
An arcane well a world tree and a moon goddess in a triune, not singular, tri-une nexus of power - I haven't seen that before.
We haven't even delved into the u iqueness of character, devotions present different philosophies yet harmony ensues.
Night elves also show a juxtaposition on co treating themes all the way through, notice the barefooted kaldorei and shal'dorei combatants despite their high civilization, yet druids live in the earth and trees but aren't primitive.
Demon hunters and sentinels, dusk guard, Moonguard, feral druids fight with a savage ferocity at complete contrast with a serenity and aloofness. Promote yet advanced, savage yet tranquil, wise yet reckless (And before you think Azshar a and her highborne how often have you seen Tyrande just charge in)
Thalassian Elf - High elf
You have high elf, blood elf, void elf, San'layn (vampire) and dark fallen(undead), wretched, fel elf(incl illidari blood elves)
First of all high elves having a strong arcane, light and forest theme, more regular in its fantasy, but still a combination not often seen, because the forest type farstriders elf usually isn't together with the arcane type, but it isn't unheard of.
Then watch how high elf is split into Blood elf and high elf with elves having different political and philosophical views.
One high elven group is working with orcs and trolls - where have you ever seen that from high elves? They also do evil and wicked things but have enough detail not to be generalised as an evil group. Where have you seen this sort of complexity and depth? And bear in mind the night elves have a different display of complexity and depth.
Then void elves, successfully able to resist a void magic theme, a polar opposite to the light but which isn't the night of the nightnelf group and it's stars and moon, a different dark. One that turns everyone evil, but these ones manage for the first time to grasp it for good at the same time we are shown how light based ones can use a good source like the light for evil.
Wretched corrupted by over consumption of magic, Sunwell and the Light a duo nexus of power - I haven't seen that in elves before till wow.
And let us not even go into the whole San'layn Vampyrismm or the Sylvanas dark rangers, farstriders, blood mage, spell breaker, priest and blood Paladin.
Other genres just have one elf about one thing. You have your wood elf, your high elf, your dark elf , some ophave all of them, but they are separate and only about 1 thing. I call that boring and tired, over used and uninteresting.
I don't call wow elves that. Not to mention the visual feast of Quel'thalas and Eversong Woods, or Suramar and Val'sharah forest each quite uniwue from the other and entirely elven complete with sun and light themes and night, stars and moon theme
Very far from boring. Very far. Elves are one of warcraft's most interesting races.
Let's not forget the detailed lore too, the night elves and their creation, pre sundering era and long vigil era and now post vigil era. From kaldorei empire, to war of the ancients, magecraft, druidcaft and demon hunterism, war of the Satyr and shifting sands, 3rd war era
The Thalassian elves and their extensive lore from their exile from the night elves, founding of Quel'thalas, Amani wars, humans and Arathor, founding of Dalaran and guardian's of tirisfal, the alliance etc all the way up to the scourge invasion, it is as detailed as the night elven lore even though it is over 7,000 year span rather than the 15,000 year one night elf kind have to their credit, and all the lore of the sundering braces like nightborne and cenarion for the night elves and void elves and San'layn for the Thalassian.