is Sharia law compatible with western society?

[the game]

As the title states. Is Sharia law compatible with western society?

[Hottage]

Short answer? No.

[Combatbutler]

No, it is not.

[Gaexion Ramza Beoulve]

Sharia Law is not even compatible with Sharia Law.

[Escepticus]

Sharia law it's not compatible with humankind, period.

[Kathandira]

As the title states. Is Sharia law compatible with western society?

Not at all. We are all about personal freedom for all. Sharia Law is about control rather than freedom.

[Dendrek]

What a useful question.

[Mighty Tim]

It will clash with the current system but no it would take us back hundred of years.

[ParanoiD84]

Lmfao is that a joke?

[hynx]

the mere fact that militias have publicly executed homosexuals, citing Sharia, should be the quick answer of no. and if there happens to be documentation that contradicts that statement, then that is even scarier, because the ignorant are still using Sharia as a vessel to kill people for simply existing; further proving that "sharia" cannot work on western countries...or even with humanity.

[s_bushido]

What kind of question is this...

[Maxilian]

Do we actually know what Sharia law is about? cause i surely don't (i just know that is things based on their prophet -what he said or did-)

[OMGTwitchTV]

Sharia Law is based on a religion. Western law is based on actual law separating Church and State. Sharia Law is more eye for an eye, so unless we want to reinstate Wild West Justice, I can't see Sharia Law fitting into America as a standard. It can either stay with the Muslim communities, or it can go back across the ocean. I won't follow those laws.

[Mighty Tim]

Do we actually know what Sharia law is about? cause i surely don't (i just know that is things based on their prophet -what he said or did-)

I am aware of most of it though exact punishments for obscure laws will escape me. Think of it as a more brutal form of the inquisition and your not far off.

[crewskater]

Obviously not. Is this a troll post? Sharia law states a woman's vote is worth half that of a mans in court.

[yetgdhfgh]

Common Law must always take precedent over religious law.

Western society is built on Common Law and it must always stay that way.

[Maxilian]

I am aware of most of it though exact punishments for obscure laws will escape me. Think of it as a more brutal form of the inquisition and your not far off.

Just saw a video explaining why the punishment for the laws are so extreme, and the logic behind it is sound (regardless if i agree with it or not) and it seems that the requirements to apply those punishment are many, so i would ASSUME that those punishment are quite rare in reality

[Sorshen]

Another bait thread from the game, slow day?

[Underverse]

Is any religious fundamentalism compatible with Western society at this point? Not really, no.

[Mighty Tim]

Common Law must always take precedent over religious law.

Western society is built on Common Law and it must always stay that way.

It might it depends what culture prevails in the next century.