Originally Posted by
Feanoro
To the reality that the WC1-2 Horde was unquestionably the villains? There were no heroes in the Old Horde, just named members of what was intended to be Warchief Legion Puppet and His Mindless Minions.
I know what they were TRYING to do with him, but they completely failed.
Er what? He was a mewling peacenik well before that book tried to make his balls drop. Always whining to Varian how they should try diplomacy because the little piss ant was too sheltered to know the crap the Horde had pulled and was continuing to pull. Questing after that little shit in MoP was annoying to no end, how he'd fuck over his own bodyguards in his endless search for a way to surrender to orc, complete with Disney level emo teen lines about "so much more to us!" Of course he didn't like Varian, Varian actually wanted him to act like a man and in his own people's interest. For example, Varian would not have backed off after BoD because the trolls were sad, ultimately costing thousands more Alliance lives.
Jaina makes sense up to a point, but only with IRL knowledge. She started out as a naive peacenik fool willing to help kill her own father. To explain away making Theramore hostile to Horde NPCs (so boats from Menethil Harbor had a destination in southern Kalimdor, remember we mostly walked), she was written as too weak to actually RULE the little bit of land she had. Since she wisely settled on an island in a desolate swamp, naively expecting the Horde to help, she had to accept Alliance aid to not starve to death or be overwhelmed by forces from the swamp. Because of accepting that aid, she had to allow Theramore to be used as an Alliance staging point/garrison.
Fast forward to Garrosh, well known for shyness, understatement, and self-restraint. Also known for hypocrisy, because WMDs like blight are cowardly and dishonorable, but WMDs like mana bombs aren't somehow. Everyone she knew was dead, but unlike her father getting cut down by Thrall and Rexxar, this time it wasn't ok because she wasn't interested in Garrosh. Sorry, letting myself indulge in how much I despise her.
In any case, she woke the hell up and realized that Thrall had been the exception, and even he had done nothing to help Theramore, leading to this point. She figured out that orcs even without the excuse of demon blood were always going to be hellbent on conquest and battle. She took another look at the Horde, which stopped being the good WC3 Horde the second they took on the NuScourge, and finally understood they had always been a threat and always would be if only because chopping heads off and blighting everything is just another day in the office for the Horde.
Her latest flop back towards peace is due to how poorly the trainwreck of BFA has been received. The writers are frantically trying to scale back the idiot faction war because they didn't understand the audience would actually care about things like Teldrassil. Since the goal is cross faction PVE to make up for being greedy bastards milking character/guild transfer money to Horde until PVE was completely wrecked, they can't have the permanent divide that BFA should logically cause.