Broxigar vs Sylvanas

[TheramoreIsTheBomb]

sylvanas is probably more powerful than the lich king at this moment

[Kallor]

And? Grommash solo killed Cenarius

Empowered by the magical blood of Mannoroth. He was buffed by someone else.

[avitush]

Hard to say, but I still think Sylvanas wins, just because we're talking about a straight-up warrior with no magical abilities vs Sylvanas, who has access to all kinds of banshee-type abilities and is a formidable fighter even aside from that. Brox might be the most badass of warriors, but that doesn't help when Sylvanas can just do her shadow blast thing or whatever it was and insta-kill him from range or vaporize his head with a banshee scream or something.

Brox has a better chance than Varok did if we're talking Brox in his prime (because Varok was well past his prime when he faced Sylvanas), and maybe the Axe of Cenarius hurts Sylvanas pretty badly if he gets close enough to hit her with it. But I still think my money would be on Sylvanas.

edit: I really don't think Sylvanas even needed her DBZ death blast for Varok. If you remember, she was pretty much toying with him, dancing around, blocking everything, landing all kinds of hits on him, etc, before she even got to that point. She only unleashed that blast because he pissed her off. Even if there'd been a "melee only" rule for that fight, I think she could've stopped playing and easily finished him off with a good stab/cut whenever she wanted.

[Maljinwo]

Warriors are probably the worst equipped people to participate in a Mak'gora, ironically

[darkoms]

Empowered by the magical blood of Mannoroth. He was buffed by someone else.

And? Brox buffeed by his axe.

[Greengrim]

Sylvanas has shown a sign of using death magic. You can use the Lich King for power comparison, as they are in the same magic branch - he was using the magic school before that of death, which is necromancy.

So the answer is no. No orc with any axe can beat that. And don't forget that she merely farted only a small bit of that thing too.

[darkoms]

Sylvanas has shown a sign of using death magic. You can use the Lich King for power comparison, as they are in the same magic branch - he was using the magic school before that of death, which is necromancy.

So the answer is no. No orc with any axe can beat that. And don't forget that she merely farted only a small bit of that thing too.

Cenarius used the magic of Life. Did not help

[Kallor]

And? Brox buffeed by his axe.

It brings me back to my original point. Warriors are useless without the help of magic.

[darkoms]

It brings me back to my original point. Warriors are useless without the help of magic.

Sylvanas as an archer is useless without her magic

[Kallor]

Sylvanas as an archer is useless without her magic

Sylvanas has innate magical abilities, she's a Dark Ranger. Warriors do not.

[Syegfryed]

Warriors are probably the worst equipped people to participate in a Mak'gora, ironically

after anything is allowed kinda got hijacked.

[Traveler Voltin]

Sylvanas as an archer is useless without her magic

can you shoot a bird in the eye with a bow form 2 miles away?

[Florena]

Pretty much this. People vastly overhype Broxigar while completely ignoring that axe.

That being said, Sylvanas wouldn't be able to just parry like she did with Varok.

Yeah. And him wounding Sargeras was more because he was beneath the titan's notice rather than being so skilled that he got a shot in on Sargeras in a straight up fight. Broxigar is a great warrior I'm sure, but I dont' think he'd have done any better than Saurfang ehre.

[Evaddon]

The...Axe of Cenarius...if you have to ask when you add that weapon into the mix...you shouldn't be the one to ask

[Maljinwo]

after anything is allowed kinda got hijacked.

Well, defying a mage and asking him not to do spells would be dishonorable as well I guess

[darkoms]

can you shoot a bird in the eye with a bow form 2 miles away?

What is the point if Arthas cut her arrows on the fly

[Traveler Voltin]

What is the point if Arthas cut her arrows on the fly

i doubt arthas was ever that fast.

[Greengrim]

Cenarius used the magic of Life. Did not help

Maybe I'm wrong but, I think he is using nature, not life. That would be the equivalent of necromancy, and put him at LK level.

[Potatowizard]

Sylvanas.

I don't even like her. But even if these characters were to meet. It would have been when Sylvanas was Ranger General Sylvanas Windrunner. And there is no way Brox would get close to her. Compared to a high elf ranger general, Broxx is just another slow / strong orc. His renowned reputation comes from slaying a bunch of equally slow, equally dumb demons and hacking at Sargeras' armor. Which by comparison, this would be like an ant that scratched your boot. Which is impressive.