MarcelianOnline posted a video making a tier list ranking melee DPS based on how fun they are.
Things taken into consideration when they ranked them were play style, talent choices and flexibility, what utility they bring, and DPS output.
I know a spec being fun isn't equal to doing the most DPS, but I agree with their point of doing very low damage is disheartening and doesn't make the spec as fun as it can be. What fun can be had doing less damage a third of the overall damage? (Looking at you, Feral)
TIER LIST
S: Unholy, Subtlety, Retribution
A: Windwalker, Outlaw, Havoc
B: Assassination, Survival, Frost (Death Knight), Fury
C: Arms
D: Feral, Enhancement
...
Do you agree or disagree with their rankings? What specs would you rank higher/lower?