Faction war doesnt necessarily preclude evil subfactions though, even if the explanation is a bit janky.
Just have Tyralyon ally with the Scarlet Crusade remnants because of Lothraxion, and suddenly we have the ability to have a pseudo-evil Alliance to defeat. Possibly even in a Stormwind raid if we are lucky.
The world revamp dream will never die!
I rather don't like that idea. I'd like to see Turalyon stick around as a strong leader.
- - - Updated - - -
Suramar is as much a remnant of a failed civilization as the Byzantine Empire was. They may not have the scale they used to, but they have all the wealth, military power, and seemingly a fairly thriving population for a city-state that just came out of a serious war. Their power is definitely enough to put them back in the spotlight.
As for Zandalar, they also have absolute authority over every other Troll empire, which means that anyone still left in Stranglethorn or Zul'Aman are completely submissive to them. This definitely means that the combined Troll race is all on the same faction—even if their empires have failed individually, they're still going pretty strong by default just given how prolific Trolls are.
Zandaalar ceased to be a superpower ages ago. They have been in a steady decline for so long, and Cataclysm wrecked their homeland. Majority of their fleet was also destroyed in 8.1. Kul Tirans are superior naval force to them. Suramar has sick magic, but just came back from a civil war that fucked lots of their forces.
Sometimes, the light of the moon is a key to other spaces. I've found a place where, for a night or two, the streets curve in unfamiliar ways. If I walk here, I might find insight, or I might be touched by madness.
Yeah but that requires build up to get that point. It doesn't just go zero to sixty we need to kill our new faction leader unless he actually ends up doing some terrible things.
I guess his victims could be the Alliance themselves but that seems unlikely. I also don't see the entire Alliance turning on him if he decides to purge Lordaeron of all the Forsaken.
Turalyon could also be made a pawn, or simply, be the reason why the darkness seeps in. The quote, "The golden one claims a vacant throne. The crown of light will bring only darkness," does not "technically" say whether the golden one is the darkness or will be the reason for it occurring. Perhaps Turalyon isn't bad BUT his position of power causes something evil to happen as a result. For example, Turalyon being on the throne instead of Genn, Anduin, or someone else, may have ramifications for some unknown reason we just don't know yet.
I was hopeful that WoD was going to culminate with an inversion of the first WarCraft - with the (alternate) Alliance invading Draenor to put the Iron Horde (and any other warmongers present) down before we could bring the conflict to alternate Azeroth. There are so many ways that the Alliance could be positioned as the antagonist - I wish they'd take the opportunity to do so. The current stable of writers, however, seems to have prescribed to a surface level understanding of the lore: that the Horde are the villains and the Alliance are the heroes. So I won't hold my breath.
You mean Alleria "I totally have control over the Cosmic Horror guys!" Windrunner might actually be a threat to the Alliance because she's a walking portal to the Void who nearly caused an outright invasion the moment she came close to the Sunwell, which she still seems intent on reclaiming?
Sometimes, the light of the moon is a key to other spaces. I've found a place where, for a night or two, the streets curve in unfamiliar ways. If I walk here, I might find insight, or I might be touched by madness.
Twas brillig
See: Zuldazar, filled with the remnants of the Amani, Gurubashi and every other given Empire or Tribe present. Vol'Jin was an outlier who had a different superpower behind him. Unless, for whatever reason, the Alliance tries to back a Troll tribe, I highly doubt any of them will try to secede from Zuldazar's oversight.
- - - Updated - - -
That's precisely what I'm thinking in regards to Suramar, at least. I think Zandalar is more powerful because of its connections to the other Troll tribes and general influence—economic and technological development are more the forte of Suramar, though, for sure. I definitely think they're an emergent power.
I mean in a potential Yrel storyline we could have Turalyon and indeed most of the Alliance agree with her early on and then slowly but surely start questioning her and then joining the Horde against her by the mid point of the expansion. Turalyon could still be the one who opens the way for her.
Or Pelagos. I mean they're literally golden now and their crown is pretty light.
I always took that to be referring to Z'rali in Revendreth making a bargain with the Venthyr (as the force of Death itself could be seen as an "enemy of all" at the time due to the Jailer's machinations).
(See also how the whispers of the Void reacted to Sylvanas in that comic)
Sometimes, the light of the moon is a key to other spaces. I've found a place where, for a night or two, the streets curve in unfamiliar ways. If I walk here, I might find insight, or I might be touched by madness.