Originally Posted by
Robozerim
Santa's a bit of a wild card. Could say that since Jack was the godfather, he's likely to be town, but it's a role that often gets flipped in these games just to mess with expectations.
Oogie Boogie I find hard to believe would be anything but scum. Best shot for a cannibal if all scum are Halloween Town denizens.
Sally has a small chance of being the recruitable that Jack was looking for, but I doubt she is. The role card mentions "faithful friend", and he barely noticed her until the end of the movie. Plus she actually opposed Jack's plan to take over Christmas, decent chance she's town.
Dr Finklestein was a business acquaintance of Jack, good candidate for team mafia.
Two faced mayor also a big supporter of Jack's efforts, good candidate for team mafia.
Zero was Jack's dog. Dog's are known for being loyal or faithful to their master. Quite possibly the "faithful friend" he sought out.