Rate The Rogue Above You.

[BradCritt]

Nothing to say really. Maybe keep the epics coming.

My armory: http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...j&cn=Destrazul

Can't really complain about that. Pretty sweet gear, though the Gladiator wrists put me off immediately. I'd go for Aldrianna's gloves when you get the chance, instead of the T10 gloves. Other than that, I really like it. Your trinket makes me jealous.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...j&cn=Bradcritt

Bear in mind I'm still gearing up and getting into raids and whatnot.

[Rukh]

Can't really complain about that. Pretty sweet gear, though the Gladiator wrists put me off immediately. I'd go for Aldrianna's gloves when you get the chance, instead of the T10 gloves. Other than that, I really like it. Your trinket makes me jealous.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...j&cn=Bradcritt

Bear in mind I'm still gearing up and getting into raids and whatnot.

I think you'd do good to get rid of the +agi/+hit gems and go with +expertise/+hit, and maybe even trade an arp for expertise, you're a long ways below expertise cap. According to EJ, the order of priority is hit until spell cap (you have), then expertise (you need), then arp and the other stuff.

Spec looks fairly generic, no problem there.

Other than that, you fail horribly because I hate pun names. D:

Honestly, our gear is very similar except for the expertise gap.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Arygos&cn=Rukh

That's mine. Note that it looks like I'm above expertise cap, but humans have this weird situation where if you have a sword and axe, you have two different expertise ratings. I'm actually at more like 27/25, so one over and one slightly under, so it's not a huge problem. I might look at swapping out a gem later though. Honestly, I get so tired of regemming 9/10 of my gear each time I get an upgrade. :X I'm being slightly lazy on the gemming trying to save money for cataclysm.

[Sickstealth]

You logged out in PvP gear so can't comment much other than farm some honor and upgrade as you can I guess. Spec also is wrong but I'm going to assume its your personal preference...


I haven't done this in a long time but go ahead and tear me a new one (I'm not a baby, I can take a punch). Using hearty rhino as my food if it helps. Thanks in advance. Oh and also still using ruptureless rotation.


http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...cn=Sickstealth


Yeah... have fun :P



Edit for link to armory.

[Powerogue]

You logged out in PvP gear so can't comment much other than farm some honor and upgrade as you can I guess. Spec also is wrong but I'm going to assume its your personal preference...
I haven't done this in a long time but go ahead and tear me a new one (I'm not a baby, I can take a punch). Using hearty rhino as my food if it helps. Thanks in advance. Oh and also still using ruptureless rotation.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...cn=Sickstealth
Yeah... have fun :P
Edit for link to armory.

whoa! 10/10. bordering the armor pen cap well, good crit, good everything man. your dps must be astronomical.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&cn=Darkmatter

i pale in comparison. also combat rogue here. give plenty of feedback

[Deleted]

whoa! 10/10. bordering the armor pen cap well, good crit, good everything man. your dps must be astronomical.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&cn=Darkmatter

i pale in comparison. also combat rogue here. give plenty of feedback

Overall not that bad, some 245 items still to replace though. Your crit is too high for the little hit rating you've got so you're over the critcap by several percent. I'm also interested why you don't gem for ArP...did you try using a spreadsheet? I can't imagine that gemming agi is better for you than ArP especially because of the crit you gain from agi which is much less valuable when over the critcap.

My armory is in the signature.

[Wrathh]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...thol&cn=Wrathh

[Deleted]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...thol&cn=Wrathh

Maybe you should rate the one above you first before posting your own armory...you know, that's what the whole topic is about, isn't it?

[Xaden]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...utus&cn=Ikfiru

And I know I'm over the expertise cap but that's just the best gear that was available to me, I do want to change it.

Oh and I didn't rate because well... he didn't really give me anything to rate :P

[Cangri]

Very nice gear and gemming. I rate 10/10. Out of curiousity, whats your dps on avg?

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Iron&cn=Cangri

I currently run a rupturless rotation and push on avg 12k+. I think this is garbage, and I should be doing more. Anyways it's a work in progress.

[Vuji]

Very nice gear and gemming. I rate 10/10. Out of curiousity, whats your dps on avg?

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Iron&cn=Cangri

I currently run a rupturless rotation and push on avg 12k+. I think this is garbage, and I should be doing more. Anyways it's a work in progress.

Holy gear similarities Batman!

That being said, don't really like 10 stats gem in cloak, and am wondering about the agi/haste in bracers. And I think you can afford to drop the hit enchant on your boots. Switch to Bladeborn IMO.

7/10

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...+Halls&cn=Vuji

[Xaden]

Some very nice gear you have there and I'm sure your dps will shoot up once you get DBW not to mention you'll be gaining like 11% ArP with it.
I give you a 10/10 because you know what you are doing and are on the right track.
I pull around 12-14k dps depending on the fights but thats with a 20% buff to answer you Cangri.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...utus&cn=Ikfiru

Posted at the same time Vuji haha that was for Cangri.

Basically the same goes for you Vuji. And once you get your DBW you'll be pushing 100% ArP lmfao nice. another 10/10

[ZeroSkyVII]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...utus&cn=Ikfiru

9/10. Some gear a little low ilevel, but there's no persecution against bad luck. You're tremendously over the expertise cap and should look into replacing your ring at the very least or doing some kind of itemization shifting to drop some of it. Hit rating is also under the poison cap without a boomkin or shadowpriest, which I'm sure you have. All in all, good stuff!

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...orms&cn=Zevren

***I'm aware I'm under the expertise cap (which is fine for Combat anyway as long as you're 20+...), I eat expertise food and push myself exactly to 26. And yes, it is a larger DPS gain than gemming for it and eating something else instead.

[StoicRoivaS]

I'd rate you, Invar, but you've already been!

here's me:

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...omath&n=mutaki

Yeah, I know my shoulder enchant's naff. I'm in bad terms with the Sons

You logged in pvp gear so I had to check wow-heroes.

So I wrote this whole long analysis as if you were a mutilate rogue, and then I saw your weapons and realized you were a combat rogue. Then I wrote the whole thing over analyzing from a combat perspective, and looked again and you have 2 assassination specs. For the love of god please don't tell me you log out in combat weapons for gearscore reasons. Frankly I'm pretty peeved that I wrote 2 full write-ups and can't accurately give you either because of some reason I'm sure I'll be annoyed with.

Long story short, here it goes: You have 2 bad encahnts, there's no reason for that. You have a hit gem while being well over the poison cap, that's bad. If you're trying to be combat, you missed the entire arp train, AP gems are probably worse than arp in your gear. If you are trying to be combat, you picked terrible choices for your tier pieces. Shoulder/glove is definitely the way mut goes. Likewise, if you're trying to be a mut rogue, you're way way under the expertise cap, and yet you gemmed at least one exp gem. This leads me to highly suspect that you're not using a spread sheet at all. If you're at all serious, you should be using one. Either AP is better or expertise is better; where you are right now, it's silly to be using a mix. Similarly, if you are indeed trying to be a mut rogue, you most definitely should be in crafted boots over those crappy arp boots. This will also get your expertise to where it should be. This one is slightly up for debate and would definitely need a sheet to determine, but in most cases, mut wants 4/5 tier and combat wants 2/5, depending on exactly which pieces you have available to you. So while I wouldn't jump you just yet for that, check a sheet and work towards 4/5 if it says you should (chest off-set).

All in all, I'm slightly confused and perturbed. 4/10?

Edit: I seem to have been defeated by the forum bug monster. This person is not at all the person above me, sorry.

So ZeroSky doesn't feel left out, I'll give him a quick once-over as well. The tear in your cloak nets you 4 agi while putting it in your chest and going with ap/haste in the yellow slot gives you 8agi. I'd have to check a sheet to be sure but I'm guessing that's more dps. Likewise, I'd be willing to bet that the other 264 cloak options are also more dps for you, but if you haven't seen them drop, then there's not a ton you can do about that. Similarly, if you have access to any of the heroic 10-man gear that you want (which your achievements would suggest you do) then you have quite a few more minor upgrades that you should be in. Again, if they just haven't dropped then so be it, but your neck is probably better as the sind-10-HM neck. Your chest is probably better as heroic frigid noose (or tier with whelp), your shoulders would definitely be better as heroic skinned whelp, your cape would possibly be better as heroic nerubian silk, and your ranged would definitely be better as the heroic BQL arp gun. Again these are pretty tiny upgrades and would need to be double checked on the sheet, but for someone with your gear, I would really expect you to be in them already. Looks fairly good otherwise. What sort of dps on saurfang/festergut?

Also on a small side note, getting 40 points of expertise from food or gems, and then swapping it right back for 40 points of arp from either foor or gems (the other one) is neither a dps gain or loss. There is no multiplier that hits food and not gems, or vice versa, so it's not really true to say that one is a gain over the other. So if you'd like to be perfectly technical, it really only matters which is easier to farm, which hearty rhino (arp) is in fact much easier.

Edit 2: I guess my armory isn't in my profile is it? Also, I think we have the same character model, so +1 internets for that I guess:

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...emaul&cn=Idaar

[Poklix]

Im at work, and cant really go through and spreadsheet your stuff, but it looks like you are a little low on both hit and expertise. These are both great stats and very high EP up to the cap. 7/10

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...=Poklix&gn=GAH

[martinkaca]

Im at work, and cant really go through and spreadsheet your stuff, but it looks like you are a little low on both hit and expertise. These are both great stats and very high EP up to the cap. 7/10

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...=Poklix&gn=GAH

Looks solid for the most part. Only thing I see that I would change is the boot enchant. If it is the engineering enchant its good but I don't see the use effect. Expertise is a little high but not much you can do about that atm.
9/10

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ar&cn=Gerogero

[Ashvael]

Maybe change your boots enchant to Cat's Swiftness if you can get the mats - it's 6 agility after all! Minor, I know.
Else, I can't see anything wrong with your gear. Keep the heroic uprades coming and you'll do just fine!

Armory link is in the signature.

[martinkaca]

Maybe change your boots enchant to Cat's Swiftness if you can get the mats - it's 6 agility after all! Minor, I know.
Else, I can't see anything wrong with your gear. Keep the heroic uprades coming and you'll do just fine!

Armory link is in the signature.

Yeah, actually forgot about that, had it on old boots but grabed this enchant out the gbank so I could just go.

Don't rate me again, rate Ashvael above me.

[teraldriel]

Maybe change your boots enchant to if you can get the mats - it's 6 agility after all! Minor, I know.
Else, I can't see anything wrong with your gear. Keep the heroic uprades coming and you'll do just fine!

Armory link is in the signature.

well, awsome gear, right gems, etc etc, really nice. on thing that i found strange;
2 combat builds? i suppose pvp combat^^
my armory : armory eu: teraldriel nordrassil eu (can't link links)
greetz, teraldriel.

[Siraeyou]

Get your engineering up so you can use the hyperspeed accelerators.
Als your expertise is kinda high, but I have that problem too =/

Havent played in over a month but here ya go.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&n=Mummr%C3%A5

[Flabb]

Give Lungbreaker.

Also, AFAIK, DBW is bad for Assasination? Not "bad" per se, just much better choices? I'd say 8/10 for this reason.

Here's Mine. http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...land&cn=Deface


EDIT: YES! I KNOW i put my gems the wrong way around in my pants, quit bugging me! :<