Rate the Protection Paladin above you!

[Ronark]

Oh man this really sucks. I was about to link you guys my Paladin.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&cn=Charmalade

Took a gander at it myself. Only to realize the I have just been hacked. This probably happened no less than 6 hours ago. I was able to change my password though...

FUJKSJDFLKSDJFUDF

You should beable to ticket it and get all your gear and items back. Maybe not with all gems/enchants,but it is better than nothing.

[Nathos]

You should beable to ticket it and get all your gear and items back. Maybe not with all gems/enchants,but it is better than nothing.

I was going to go rate you, but you're not a tank
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...maul&cn=Nathos

[Psyjin]

Your gear is amazing, makes me massively jealous, especially the legs, I've been after those for ages and on the first guild raid I've not attended in months they dropped for our other pally. Although I will never understand why any prot pally would take Seal of Command!

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ker&cn=Aoeadin

[Deathlycold]

heres my dwarfadin

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ight&cn=Jupile

[gentlecasca]

Your gear is amazing, makes me massively jealous, especially the legs, I've been after those for ages and on the first guild raid I've not attended in months they dropped for our other pally. Although I will never understand why any prot pally would take Seal of Command!

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ker&cn=Aoeadin

The gear is decent; I'm not really expecting to see a profile that has the absolute best in the game; you should have focused on t10 first though...All it takes is the old piece and a Mark of Sanctification to get a piece that's even better. The Glyph of Indomitability isn't that great, but I know Satrina's wouldn't drop for me for awhile, so I can't fault you for that.

Our glyphs are the same. xD Awesome.

Your spec. is cool, but I'm not too keen on Dsac. Some Protadins swear by it, but I'd question its usefulness. I know it was a hell of a lot of fun to pop during Faction Champs, but in ICC I haven't encountered a situation where the group needed it. Also, I noticed you have 2/2 Vindication; any particular reason why? You're better off switching those points out of Seals of the Pure, Dsac, and Vindication to grab the increased Crit. % and Crusade; Crusade is pretty awesome, no lie.

Also, the reason why certain Paladins take SoCasino...Er, Command, is because it generates decent threat in Trash Packs and on AoE fights. It basically turns your ShoTR and Judgment into an HoTR. I'll give you an 8/10, buddy.

Armory is messed up; can't find my page. Soooo...Name is Kilgannon and he's on Rexxar.

Sorry for not pasting a link. -_-

[Banan]

Armory above doesn't work.

Link in sig

[aarkom]

heres my dwarfadin

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ight&cn=Jupile

Couldnt really rate this im afraid as you seem to be in your ret gear. Did havea quick look at your prot talents and i dont understand why you have chosen certain talents. It my understanding that Divinity is just bad, as is Improved Hammer of Justice, also you have 2 points instead of just 1 in Spiritual Attunement. I dont know what you use your tanking spec for as can not see your level of gear. These 8 talents points would probably be better spent in the ret tree. May i note that my knowledge of pala tanking is quite basic, and these are just my observations.

Heres my armoury link please be gentle, this paladin is my 5th level 80, but am enjoying tankin loads with her and contemplating maybe using her as my main in Cat. I have got 60 frost badges to use but cannot decide what to use them on, my thoughts are either the belt or T10 shoulders. Any constructive critasicim or advice is welcome.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...&cn=Darn%C3%AD

[gentlecasca]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...r&cn=Kilgannon

The link should work now. Bring it on.

[Elessa]

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...&cn=Darn%C3%AD

Why don't you gem for a 12 stam bonus? You gemmed for two 6stam bonuses, why not gemf or the 9stam aswell? I know you just need one red gem to activate the meta, but skipping a 12stam bonus is stupid. Wheter you gem for 9stam bonuses is your decision, but don't gem for 6 ones please.
Get the 226 crafted belt, or the one from conquest emblems. (or any other really, but those are easy to get)
You're an engineer! Get the 885 armor on your gloves, it's an awesome enchant!
Try to grab the Rimefang Claw sword from PoS Heroic, the shield block on your weapon is kind of meh. However if you don't think the effort/money spent on enchant is worth it, don't do it since it's not a major upgrade (barely a minor one).

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...r&cn=Kilgannon

The link should work now. Bring it on.

Spec is good. There is not anything wrong with tou gear, although you could get a better necklace from HoR 5 Heroic, unless you badly need that hit. You could change your dodge/stam gem to a agi/stam gem, it is slightly superior.

There is one thing bothering me about your armory though... NO DUAL SPEC? ....the fuck! Dual spec is amazing! You are the only well geared lvl 80 I've seen without it o_O


This is me: http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...oda&gn=Chronos
My main spec is holy, which is the reason for not having any emblem of frost items
I run without seal of venhence because i only run heroics/solo with this spec at the moment, will get it asap when I raid.
The reason for a dps weapon is the same as the latter one, it works pretty nicely with seal of command!
I do have the weapon from anub 10 man in my bags though.

[Automatic]

...snip...

This is me: http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...oda&gn=Chronos
My main spec is holy, which is the reason for not having any emblem of frost items
I run without seal of venhence because i only run heroics/solo with this spec at the moment, will get it asap when I raid.
The reason for a dps weapon is the same as the latter one, it works pretty nicely with seal of command!
I do have the weapon from anub 10 man in my bags though.

I think you could safely remove some of the +def enchants/gems you have (less-so the gems if the socket bonus is worth it) as you're rocking a mighty 572 Def at the moment. I've heard of protadins using a DPS weapon in heroics, to speed things up, but is zerking a good enchant for the weapon? Sure the proc will help out with DPS and the armor loss is pretty minor (5% is it?) but does the benefit really outweigh the negative?

For spec and glyphs, most things look ok for a heroics only tank. I would say you could comfortably drop glyph of RD. I have around the same amount of hit and never see a taunt fail.

On to me:

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ds&n=Automatic

I pick up Vindication because until recently we ran mostly without a ret. Although we have one now, so I can safely shift those points. Also I find command to be useful on a few ICC fights + the obvious benefit of heroics. In particular Valithria Dreamwalker and LK phase 1 add tanking command shines.

[Elessa]

I think you could safely remove some of the +def enchants/gems you have (less-so the gems if the socket bonus is worth it) as you're rocking a mighty 572 Def at the moment. I've heard of protadins using a DPS weapon in heroics, to speed things up, but is zerking a good enchant for the weapon? Sure the proc will help out with DPS and the armor loss is pretty minor (5% is it?) but does the benefit really outweigh the negative?

For spec and glyphs, most things look ok for a heroics only tank. I would say you could comfortably drop glyph of RD. I have around the same amount of hit and never see a taunt fail.

On to me:

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ds&n=Automatic

I pick up Vindication because until recently we ran mostly without a ret. Although we have one now, so I can safely shift those points. Also I find command to be useful on a few ICC fights + the obvious benefit of heroics. In particular Valithria Dreamwalker and LK phase 1 add tanking command shines.

I chose the def/dodge shoulder enchant because I find it more useful than the pvp one.
About the cloak enchant, I used this cloak ever since i started farming heroics for gear, back then I needed the defense. I have not been arsed to change it since the diffrence between this one and the armor one is very slight.
And yes, zerking is awesome. It helps us get through trash/heroics faster, and in heroics and on trash -5% armor is not a problem at all, it's not even noticeable since I barely take any damage in heroics anyway.



don't forget to rate this guy http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ds&n=Automatic

[gentlecasca]

Spec is good. There is not anything wrong with tou gear, although you could get a better necklace from HoR 5 Heroic, unless you badly need that hit. You could change your dodge/stam gem to a agi/stam gem, it is slightly superior.

There is one thing bothering me about your armory though... NO DUAL SPEC? ....the fuck! Dual spec is amazing! You are the only well geared lvl 80 I've seen without it o_O

Not to hijack, but I felt as though I needed to respond. I actually had no idea about the 5-man HoR Heroic Necklace and I'll be looking into that tomorrow evening for sure. I've read about the agi/stam vs dodge/stam and never really had the urge to change it; call it superstition. xD In regards to the dual spec., I can't see the point in spending 1kg, even though that's peanuts, to buy something I will never, EVER use. I'm the guild's MT and they know that I eat, sleep, and breathe tanking...To say the very least. :P

Alright; I'm gone. Enjoy your rating!

[Aedh]

don't forget to rate this guy http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...ds&n=Automatic

@that dude.

STFU

I hate you and your.

Everything is solid.

I think....
9.99/10

[retrofade]

Well I don't see anything else to rate right now, so...

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...oon&cn=cylonna

[Aedh]

Well I don't see anything else to rate right now, so...

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...oon&cn=cylonna

Note to self.......point out that the sig image can be turned into a link to the armory.....

Also rate that person.

[rillepille]

The paladin tank above me gets thumbs up for stacking spirit gems. You go girl!

[Veq]

I've respecced 2 weeks ago, got fed up with being one of 98759789356 rets.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...aelstrom&n=Veq

Any advice?

[Aedh]

The paladin tank above me gets thumbs up for stacking spirit gems. You go girl!

I know you don't I?

[infra]

I've respecced 2 weeks ago, got fed up with being one of 98759789356 rets.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...aelstrom&n=Veq

Any advice?

DS+DG is well worth the 3 talent points for plenty of raid situations in ICC (use a cancel macro to immediately remove the damage transfer DS portion leaving behind the DG 20% raidwide damage reduction).

Reckoning sounds like a cool talent but it's not really a great use of 5 talent points.


Mine:

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Imperial+Redux

This is my alt. I run a GDKP pug which has helped me gear up tremendously. I don't think there's an upgrade left for me prior to LK25 (not looking at 10Hs) but would be interested if that's not the case. I'm reasonably glyph aware and have plenty of glyphs to swap out the RD glyph to something else depending on the encounter in question.

Advice would be much appreciated.

[Fadian]

Infra this is my opinion on your spec and such....

You should never have mana issues, so take out the point in benediction

Also with a lot of raid makeup vindication is a waste, warriors and such can do that with a simple shout.

Pursuit of justice is a waste also. To be able to move faster? shouldn't need to worry about that. a lot of moving is either avoiding flames or some kite fights but you will always be fast enough.

I would put another point into improve judgments and the rest into Conviction. Not only will it help with more threat in time, but also help increase your overall dps to assist the raid.

As for glyphs. I never worry about expertise. So I miss now and then on some abilities, but with the threat gen I produce from crits and other abilities, a miss here and there wont hinder me one bit. As for the taunt glyph, it's okay and not okay. for me in all honesty i have two forms of a taunt, if one misses, chances are, the other will make it.

Divine sacrifice is one thing. In my opinion its a waste now that they nerfed it. for a OT it would be okay though where you can help mitigate damage. I do however like to put points in reckoning. With seal of command and that, you can do more AoE damage to hold agro better with extra swings. Everything else looks good. talent and glyph wise.

Gear wise, your better then me lol.



here is mine

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...rall&cn=Fadian

The only freaking thing i can never get is a damn upgraded shield. all the times i did ICC10. ToC and ToGC25 no freakin shield drops. none! never! it's frustrating sporting that damn naxx shield still. lol