Rate the Protection Paladin above you!

[Deleted]

Cant access armory at work so cant check your character Zyro.
Would love some feedback on my current setup. Reforged hit because i maintank halfus hc and need it to get alittle closer to hit cap for the kicks.

Character: Laserurban. Stormscale EU ( Cant post links yet. )
I also got the Mirror of Broken Images from TB and i switch that with the Figurine depending on bosses.

It seems nice overall but still (im not expert but heres what i think, correct me if im wrong) that avoidence is better then Health these days so you could change some stam gems to avoidence instead aswell maybe get the tank crafted belt from blacksmithing?
myself i got windwalk for the extra suvival sometimes

And if someone could give me feedback: Zyro - Shattered hand

thanks hope i havnt been rude or something

[Gobs]

Rip my guy apart. Want to make sure I'm perfect for the Cho'gall fight next week. Build/Gem/Gear/Reforge/Stats

tenderdidy
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...rdidy/advanced

[Nybras]

Rip my guy apart. Want to make sure I'm perfect for the Cho'gall fight next week. Build/Gem/Gear/Reforge/Stats

tenderdidy
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...rdidy/advanced

Take 1 point out of rule of law and pickup divine guardian.
Use the mirror of broken images, more mastery and the use is incredible.
Dodge enchant on bracers
If you use the dps neck for tanking, reforge to mastery. Otherwise pick the JP neck with mastery.
Chest- change to stam/mastery gem.
Legs- do a 20parry/20mastery to pickup the socket bonus.
Get exalted with therazane asap.
Get exalted with Earthen ring and reforge the agi ring's haste to dodge. (your parry rating is a good bit higher than your dodge rating)

Just the things I saw at a quick glance.

[Rahzel619]

I can't post any links, but my character is Rahzel on US-Jaedenar. Any critiques would be appreciated.

[Deleted]

I can't post any links, but my character is Rahzel on US-Jaedenar. Any critiques would be appreciated.

Rating http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ahzel/advanced


Pretty well done honestly, I would go for Eternal Glory instead of Pursuit of Justice in the spec though.

You should change your JC gems to Mastery, as stamina is pretty much the worst stat until you meet some of the real hardmodes (and even then it's not better than avoidance) You should also go for 2x mastery gems in your belt instead of stamina.

Here's my alternative character, be nice!

ps; missing shoulder enchant because of lacking rep, just realized they fixed head enchant BOA's in 4.0.6

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...iesta/advanced

[Cowsftl]

Rating http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ahzel/advanced


Pretty well done honestly, I would go for Eternal Glory instead of Pursuit of Justice in the spec though.

You should change your JC gems to Mastery, as stamina is pretty much the worst stat until you meet some of the real hardmodes (and even then it's not better than avoidance) You should also go for 2x mastery gems in your belt instead of stamina.

Here's my alternative character, be nice!

ps; missing shoulder enchant because of lacking rep, just realized they fixed head enchant BOA's in 4.0.6

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...iesta/advanced

Are you kidding me? Avoidance isn't great. Mainly because of DR. There are a lot of unavoidable stuff in this tier. You could argue that migitation is better than stamina, but saying avoidance is better than stamina is wrong.

[shavok]

I figure I should chime in to help get my constructive posts up for my account:

This is a link to my tank (which is an alt) who hasn't seen much raid time. I'll be getting windwalk today/tomorrow.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...eiros/advanced

I've posted my CTC equipment list. I've also got 2 stam trinkets to change out for magic-based damage encounters.

[Deleted]

Are you kidding me? Avoidance isn't great. Mainly because of DR. There are a lot of unavoidable stuff in this tier. You could argue that migitation is better than stamina, but saying avoidance is better than stamina is wrong.

Tell me one fight you'll get 2-3 or maybe even 4 shotted by magic damage (namely without being a complete retard)

Either way if your healers can't keep you up on magic damage fights like cho'gall heroic you're either failing on cooldowns or your healers are undergeared.

[Gobs]

Take 1 point out of rule of law and pickup divine guardian.
Use the mirror of broken images, more mastery and the use is incredible.
Dodge enchant on bracers
If you use the dps neck for tanking, reforge to mastery. Otherwise pick the JP neck with mastery.
Chest- change to stam/mastery gem.
Legs- do a 20parry/20mastery to pickup the socket bonus.
Get exalted with therazane asap.
Get exalted with Earthen ring and reforge the agi ring's haste to dodge. (your parry rating is a good bit higher than your dodge rating)

Just the things I saw at a quick glance.

Which trinket do you recommend I switch out for the mirrors?

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...rdidy/advanced

[Cowsftl]

Tell me one fight you'll get 2-3 or maybe even 4 shotted by magic damage (namely without being a complete retard)

Either way if your healers can't keep you up on magic damage fights like cho'gall heroic you're either failing on cooldowns or your healers are undergeared.

If you think avoidance is better than stamina your wrong. When you get over 14-15% parry/dodge you'll gain so little because of the DR. However stamina doesn't suffer from DR. Think again.

[Deleted]

i would love some feedback aswell have been trying 2 times now but noone have give me anything

"Zyro" on "Shattererd hand" thanks guys

[Deleted]

If you think avoidance is better than stamina your wrong. When you get over 14-15% parry/dodge you'll gain so little because of the DR. However stamina doesn't suffer from DR. Think again.

How weak minded can one be..

You want to go for 102.4% avoidance, with the majority of that being block, though you still have to balance dodge and parry.

go read on maintankadin/EJ instead of spewing out nonsense next time

[Cowsftl]

How weak minded can one be..

You want to go for 102.4% avoidance, with the majority of that being block, though you still have to balance dodge and parry.

go read on maintankadin/EJ instead of spewing out nonsense next time

Oh gosh... Avoidance isn't the same thing as migitation.

When you say avoidance, I think you mean avoidance and not migitation. Read up next time please.

[Deleted]

Oh gosh... Avoidance isn't the same thing as migitation.

When you say avoidance, I think you mean avoidance and not migitation. Read up next time please.

I'll reword it for simple minded people such as yourself, getting what is also called unhittable which is 102.4% avoidance/mitigation.

I'll even be nice and link you threads where you can learn to play.

http://elitistjerks.com/f76/t110338-...#Stat_Overview

http://maintankadin.failsafedesign.c...rb_v=viewtopic

[Cowsftl]

I'll reword it for simple minded people such as yourself, getting what is also called unhittable which is 102.4% avoidance/mitigation.

I'll even be nice and link you threads where you can learn to play.

http://elitistjerks.com/f76/t110338-...#Stat_Overview

http://maintankadin.failsafedesign.c...rb_v=viewtopic

I know what unhittable means. You said avoidance wich is Parry/dodge. Parry and dodge suffers from DR wich makes them much less valuable. Therefor after you reach 12-13% parry/dodge Stamina is better than both.

You should learn the difference between migitation and avoidance.

[Deleted]

I know what unhittable means. You said avoidance wich is Parry/dodge. Parry and dodge suffers from DR wich makes them much less valuable. Therefor after you reach 12-13% parry/dodge Stamina is better than both.

You should learn the difference between migitation and avoidance.

Oh please, I'm starting to think every swede is like this, lol.

it was obviously a bad use of wording, I don't get why you have to get upset about it unless you've got PMS which means you shouldn't be here in the first place.

[Ruzhyo]

I rate the tank above me as banned.

Not sure if I can post links yet but here I go:
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...uzhyo/advanced
EDIT: Balls I just noticed my glove gem.

[Batty]

Battyrr
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...ttyrr/advanced

I realize i can swap to mastery gemming, and i also realize i could swap to double mastery trinks, atm im in a somewhat casual guild working on nef, for which i am tanking nef, so the stam is more useful there i believe..

[Deleted]

Stamina is never "more useful".. If your tank healer can't perform well enough to outheal the incoming damage - he is bad. I have something like 175k hp and 98% avoidance/mitigation buffed. Never seen a fight where healer couldn't keep me up. I'm working on the second trinket from TB as it will boost up 4.5% block getting me just on that well known "cap" - 102.4% After that I'm planing to go for hit rating to boost threat a bit, cause sometimes I have to use salvation on top dps..

[trulofy]

I know what unhittable means. You said avoidance wich is Parry/dodge. Parry and dodge suffers from DR wich makes them much less valuable. Therefor after you reach 12-13% parry/dodge Stamina is better than both.

You should learn the difference between migitation and avoidance.

but stam is not better than mastery in any way until you hit 102.4% so gemming for stam if your not unhittable is just plain dumb because there is no DR for block.