Originally Posted by
buck008
Conscript... the Giants at 8-8 and not even in the playoffs? Philly at 11-5? Come on. If Vick was 100% and played all 16 games, I don't see the Eagles winning 11 games. That defense is vastly overrated, and since Jim Johnson passed, it had gotten steadily worse. There are pretty good reasons that team struggled offensively last year as well, and the decaying corpse of Vick is only part of it. Plus, you know, Andy Reid. I'm also waaaaay lower on the NFC South than you guys seem to be. I think New Orleans is a mess, but wins by default because Atlanta is a flawed team but a decent one, and Carolina just isn't there yet.