I want my phoenix hatchling pet. Now! I mean, seriously...
The story: I started farming the mount preparing myself for a long grind, thinking I'd get the pet and orb first, then would have to keep going for the mount. Long story short, I got the mount on 2nd run, the orb on the 5th, still don't have the hatchling after 17 kills... (add to that some normal mode farming too afterwards)
Other rare mount stories:
- got the Deathcharger on my first kill ever. I started playing shortly before TBC, so never ran Stratholme. In TBC I solo farmed the Idol of Brutality (there's still a really old post of mine on wowhead about it) but never went as far as Baron. Came back at lvl 80 (farming runecloth for my dk alt for horde factions rep), went to Baron and BAM! the mount. I had no idea how rare it was. Linked it in gchat, got some abuse, then mentioned it was my first kill and I think that got me on a few ignore lists for a while
- I have the FoS for the original swift flight form quest line, killed Anzu quite a few times in TBC with no luck. Went back at 80 no luck. Now been farming it every day since they put the Orgri portal back in Shattrath... still no luck so far.
- I did the daily for polar bear every day for at least 6 months in WOTLK (towards the end) and part of Cata (I have the argent tourny tabard so it helped a lot). I have got the Salty title during WOTLK (got the Sea Turtle while farming the rare fish--"Dark Herring" in my case), but never managed to get the Giant Sewer Rat... which I got on my DK due to overly long hc dps queues. I also have the polar bear on this dk alt, so I was really pissed off. A couple of months ago I had a couple of hours to kill so I thought I'd do the quest and some serious giant rat farming in Dalaran (knowing that I already had 600+ casts w/o seeing it). I do the quest and hurrah! the mount drops. Fly to Dalaran, within 10 casts I had the rat too. And still of couple of hours on my hands
One last story: one night we didn't have enough sign-ups for a raid to happen and decided to fish for the seafood recipe achiv. Since I already have maxxed fishing and the sea turtle on my main, I decided to skill up fishing with an alt, who had ~100 fishing when I started.
(another guildie got it before me, the same night, as mentioned in the chat)