Kane always has been better than Toews. Marchand is better than Chara. Brown wasn't even a top tier player in LA when they won the cup. Cbj, nj, win all doing fine without best players as captains. Only team with the best player as captain that won the cup since 2008 was Pittsburgh. Doesn't need to be the best player but seems the league is moving back to that more and more lately.
Matthews without a doubt should be our captain for every reason though.