Which set up is better?

[Dorfie]

Disc + Disc + Shaman

or

Disc + Holy + Shaman

Yeah our 10 man is a bit fucked but which is better?

[keRmis]

Disc + Disc + Shaman

or

Disc + Holy + Shaman

Yeah our 10 man is a bit fucked but which is better?

I'd go with Disc + Holy. 2 discs in a 10man scenario... yuck.

[Deleted]

2 disc in any scenario is bad, really very bad

[Bluepoet]

One of each...two Discs is not horrible, but awkward....like, having two ladies appear, at the dance, in the same outfit...

Besides, I like to click on the Holy well, while bubbled....

[Liliyah]

2 disc in any scenario is bad, really very bad

2 discs is perfectly acceptable, and dare I say optimal, in some 25 man scenarios.
10 man, I'd say double disc is generally a pretty blah idea except for single-target healing scenarios where there would be little healing overlap with two priests, such as on Baleroc.

[babylon]

2 disc in 10man, been there, never again. timing raptures itself can become a nightmare

[Noradin]

Two Discs can work better than Disc + Holy under some circumstances, even for 10m.
It works well on all figths were enough tagets get damage to make full use for rapture for both Discs possible (a little bit of organisation is sometimes needed).
We did it on Baleroc heroic, I think (only 2 disc no other healers) and on Bethilac (one disc goes upstairs).

Sometimes we don't have a optimal setup, and since I'm Shadow normally and don't care for Holy I will just go Disc whenever I heal. Our other priest prefers Disc, too, so if we both need to heal and it is possible we will both go Disc unless we could use Body and Soul. None of us mindlessly spamms shields so on most encounters we both get our rapture procs in without a problem.

[Collins]

disc + holy