I'm actually running around with the firelands rep cloak as I think melee does not fit running around in long, ground sweeping cloaks (unless you're going for some sort of jedi transmorg).
Thought I founs myself terrified when I was looking at the VP cloaks we had this patch, oh my lord, what have they done with the crit/hit one? Is it deathwing who have tried to knitting it or why is it rendered apart? Q.Q