Originally Posted by
Accaris
If you're topping rogues, mages, DKs, warlocks, or hunters as Arms, then your DPSers are really, really bad. Arms is simply not one of the top 8 DPS specs right now on any single target encounter. Logs and parses support this universally.
EDIT: Here's how it breaks down on World of Logs:
MSV:
Feng: 3 in the top 400
Garaj: 2 in the top 400
Spirit Kings: 1 in the top 400
Elegon: 1 in the top 400
Emperor: 1 in the top 400
HOF/Terrace:
Imperial Vizier: 6 in the top 400
Blade Lord: 14 in the top 400 (due to Execute phase)
Wind Lord: 0 in the top 400
Amber Shaper: 3 in the top 400
Empress: 7 in the top 400
Protector: 0 in the top 400
Plenty of Fury warriors though. Imo for a guild concerned solely with PvE progression, it is unwise to play Arms, because it's simply outclassed by almost every other DPS spec in the game.