Ok maybe, maybe the stop attack was a legitimate suggestion. If you look at the log though, there is no significant chunks of downtime or his instantaneous dps would drop far lower than it ever did. If he had put any effort into looking at the section with lust, he would have seen there was no real downtime during that either. The OP had 20 trinket procs so that idea is rather silly as well. It looks like the OP is just losing single hits somewhere.
Nothing may be easily lifted out of the logs, you're right. That doesn't mean you can't easily tell a dumb suggestion is dumb by looking at them though.