You are repeating yourself and not making any sense. He didn't publish those works because they weren't finished. Therefore, by that fact alone, he didn't want them to be viewed by the public in any format. So you are repeating the same absurd illogical reasoning that just makes no sense and has nothing to do with facts.....
I understood you the first time, you aren't saying anything different and it still is false.
So stop wasting time repeating yourself and just leave it.
I don't agree with you because your reasoning is nonsense.
- - - Updated - - -
Most of the 'fantastical' parts of Tolkien are the fantasy creatures almost every thing else is modeled on real world history. The armor, weapons and combat are all modeled on real world equivalents. One unique part is that some of the weapons and style of fighting varies among the various races. Otherwise, it is not a fantasy like World of Warcraft with different schools of magic and magical combat. The only thing that makes the combat in fantastical is the scale, where typical large battles have thousands and thousands of orcs versus thousands of humans and so forth. Obviously you don't see any of that in this series. The numenoreans barely were able to put together 5 ships for this mission and those ships were small in size. While in the actual lore, the Numenorean navy was so huge it covered the entire sea to the horizon and they built the largest ships ever to sail on Arda before or since. And this show obviously went against all of that with these small scale battles and so forth. The southlings or southlanders have a few raggedy huts and not even a single walled town and they face off against a few orcs. And of course a tower manned by a handful of elves that were easily captured. So none of the scale that you would expect in something written by Tolkien.
I know I posted it before but this is the kind of epic combat of high fantasy that is all inspired by Tolkien. And the large warrior could be seen as something like what a Numenorean is in Tolkien.
And most people experience high fantasy from video games like this, so compared to that, what we see in this series is much less epic.