Question to the players of the Alliance, would you forgive or take revenge?

[darkoms]

If the Alliance had the same division as the Horde (support Sylvanas or Saurfang), but related to whether to forgive the Horde or take revenge, which would you choose? I don't know what percentage of Horde players chose one side or the other, but I always thought that there were always far fewer loyalists (after all, the choice itself was added only after Sylvanas fans cried), but for some reason I'm sure that most players The Alliance would choose revenge on the entire Horde, even if Sylvanas left

[uncl55]

Revenge, i'm sick of being part of the pussy Alliance

[Divada]

Depends on race. Night Elf? On Night Elf land? Kill on sight, period. The others can be pragmatic/forgiving.

[Lord Pebbleton]

Revenge. We never had proper revenge, just damage containment after the horde did something bad. Our leaders are morons and they will never allow it, though

[Al Gorefiend]

Alliance need to WMD the Horde and the Horde's story can shift back to survival through banding together. Wish the Alliance would be more aggressive with the Horde resisting. It's always the other way around. Now that Anduins not the Alliance leader anymore let's hope for a more vengeful Alliance.

[shise]

Nothing good would come out of revenge, the goal is to have peace.

Horde vs alliance fights, which has been the theme for the most part, never brought anything good.

[Aucald]

Moved this thread to the RP subforum as it's not really about lore, but more player reactions to it, more in lieu of roleplaying in light of lore than discussing actual lore.

[Lochton]

If the Alliance had the same division as the Horde (support Sylvanas or Saurfang), but related to whether to forgive the Horde or take revenge, which would you choose? I don't know what percentage of Horde players chose one side or the other, but I always thought that there were always far fewer loyalists (after all, the choice itself was added only after Sylvanas fans cried), but for some reason I'm sure that most players The Alliance would choose revenge on the entire Horde, even if Sylvanas left

Entire Horde? Nah. Just the loyalists should feel the wrath (and that counts for Gallywix and Garrosh loyalists as well). The rest, I'm okay with.

[Zendhal The Black]

I would go full Warhammer 40000 Inquisition on Horde ass

That could make a few great stories...

But blizzard narrative team is all about peace and family and happyness and non toxic masculinity... whatever the F that is

[Vakna]

No forgiveness, ever. Not until every single soldier who followed Sylvanas' orders pays in the same way that the children of Teldrassil paid.

[bloodmoth13]

Battle for lordaeron should have happened before teldrassil. The alliance had every reason to advance on lordaeron, horde had no justification for teldrassil.
Alliance stepping up would have been awesome, horde getting revenge would have been justified.

Everything else could have been the same, hordes lore made zero sense going into BFA.

As for revenge, I don't play alliance but I'd pick revenge, and the fact they are not allowed to is the reason I won't play alliance.

If blizz gave a shit about lore they would have done it in that order.

[Progenitor Aquarius]

Forgive, because there has been shown on many occasions that when we start to fight with each other the greater enemy of Azeroth takes an advantage of it. So we should unify and gather our forces to fight the main threat instead.

[Rendark]

Revenge the most worthless of causes.

[OwenBurton]

No forgiveness, ever. Not until every single soldier who followed Sylvanas' orders pays in the same way that the children of Teldrassil paid.

I think these kinds of polls should have at least a third choice, two choices are too absolutist and simple, and forcing people to choose between two very flawed choices.

Both forgiveness and revenge are foolish paths for the night elves and the Alliance at present. It is naive to forget everything that they have lost, all those countless lives and settlements destroyed, but it is equally misguided to pursue vengeance when the world now finally has a chance to heal, and the Horde is perhaps still stronger and more united than the Alliance in any case (the night elves have lost a huge part of their civilian and military forces).

I think they should at least try to uneasily tolerate each other (for the moment). Not because it is the best choice (it really isn't), but because there are VERY few other realistic choices that would not risk self-destruction.

[Dartz1979]

If the Alliance had the same division as the Horde (support Sylvanas or Saurfang), but related to whether to forgive the Horde or take revenge, which would you choose? I don't know what percentage of Horde players chose one side or the other, but I always thought that there were always far fewer loyalists (after all, the choice itself was added only after Sylvanas fans cried), but for some reason I'm sure that most players The Alliance would choose revenge on the entire Horde, even if Sylvanas left

i would forgive sylvanas cause well her and alleria are both my favorite elf waifus...that and theya re alot better looking than tyrande.

[LordVargK]

Step 1: Reform the purge squad
Step 2: ???
Step 3: Profit.

[Polybius]

I play both, but Revenge. They can find peace in the Shadowlands.

So tired of Horde having plot armor and its loyal players defending that level of incapacity. There's no "honor" in beating a neutered faction.

[username993720]

Revenge.
This is Warcraft we're playing, not lovecraft.

[darkoms]

Revenge.
This is Warcraft we're playing, not lovecraft.

https://wowpedia.fandom.com/wiki/Old_God

[username993720]

https://wowpedia.fandom.com/wiki/Old_God

It was a pun.
I meant it's not Barnie and carebear style of game.