I agree. Basically what it boils down to, in my words, is cataclysm “failed” NOT because it was actually bad.. But actually because of the average players ignorance and desire to be “right” was stronger than their sense of adventure. Something that can still be observed to this day.
Now, the one exception to that is the fact that Dragon Soul lasted so long. But then again, who knows.. there’s a chance if people were less ready to grab the torches at anything that wasn’t immediately understood, Blizzard would’ve had a chance to flesh something else out for us.
We know there was another raid planned in Vashjir.. If the community was more receptive, this raid could’ve changed the way we talk about cataclysm in a big way.