Hi guys, I am looking at the log of my guild's heroic Ultraxion overall wiped attempts and I found something quite puzzling.
First off, here is the log: http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/r...one/?enc=wipes
We run three shadow priests, with the two lower ones sub'ed in/out mid-fight.
Here are their armory links:
(L) http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...odead/advanced (minus the 410 chest, he had 391 FL chest on boss kill)
(S) http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...%B9st/advanced
(B) http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...essid/advanced
As you can see, L has better gear, S and B are on par but S has the legendary staff. When all spriest are in the raid, the dps is: L>>S>=B. With L and S receiving DI most of the time.
What puzzles me is their Mind Blast damage. Here is a chart for easy comparsion:
Hit/Crit Average over 35 tries
L 45987 / 94179
S 42660 / 92603
B 47396 / 98468
So, L has around ~12K spell power fully buffed, S has 11.2K. I am not sure about B, but S should have more spell power (407 more net int unbuffed) than B after 10 stacks from <Will of Unbinding>
L has no 4xT12 bonus, S and B both have that. S have legendary staff but it does not matter. Then why would S have the lowest MB damage? It looks like B received his 4T12 bonus but S did not.
Here are some more data on their other major damage spells.
MF ~~~~VT ~~~ SW:P
L ~~~10741 / 22579 ~~~ 11479 / 24060 ~~~ 5800 / 12180
S ~~~ 9522 / 20066 ~~~ 10183 / 21570 ~~~ 5545 / 11542
B ~~~ 9572/20050 ~~~ 10325 / 21766 ~~~ 5592 / 11733
It is simply strange to see S doing less of all spells given his gear was slightly superior to B.
Lastly, a comparison of their basic stats from Armory:
Int ~~~ Haste ~~~ Mastery ~~~ Crit
L(Goblin) ~~~ 7073 (+880) ~~~ 22.19%~~~ 16.84~~~ 14.12%
S(BE) ~~~ 6559 (+780) ~~~ 24.12% ~~~ 11.80 ~~~ 14.47%
B(Goblin) ~~~ 6932 ~~~ 20.99% ~~~ 11.11 ~~~ 18.07%
Your input is appreciated.
---------- Post added 2011-12-30 at 04:24 PM ----------
S joined the raid right after a server transfer. Is there a transfer sickness?