What would you rate each x-pac 1-10???

[Tsuna]

Vanilla deserves 10/10 for classic Alterac Valley alone.

You could scrap the entire rest of vanilla wow and just give me classic Alterac Valley and I would play it all day lol. The fact that there was so many other great things about vanilla blows my mind. It is sad to think of all the players who never played vanilla and never got to experience Alterac Valley when it was awesome.

I agree that AV was a beautiful thing. It was always such a strange thing to go to sleep, go to school the next day, and then go back home to log in and get into the very same AV that had been going on the day before.

[Deleted]

Vanilla = 9/10
B/C = 10/10
LK = 6/10
Cata = 3/10
MoP = 8/10

[oblivionx]

Vanilla 6/10
Burning Crusade 7/10
Wrath 9/10
Cata 4/10
MOP 5/10

[Ledecor]

Vanilla: Didn't play
BC: 9/10
Wrath: 7/10 Leveling was such an annoying thing to do during Wrath for me, and still is now. Everything else was fine though.
Cata: 7/10 Raids were good (Besides Dragon Soul, which was just a miserable excuse for a raid) but everything else was just annoying for me.
MoP: 5/10 Raids don't feel exciting anymore, too much dailies to do, asian theme isn't really for me.

[Mawnix]

Vanilla - 10
TBC - 10
Wrath - 9
Cata - 3
Pandas & P8k@mon - 1

Guess we're still at this level of immaturity.

[Shalaman]

Vanilla - Didn't play
TBC - 7/10
WotLK - 10/10
Cata - 8/10
MoP - Quit here, haven't bothered playing it.

[Vulcanasm]

Vanilla = 10/10 early, 4/10 late
BC = 7/10
LK = 10/10
Cata = 0/10
MoP = 6/10

Vanilla became worse and worse the more they became monomaniacally raid-obsessed. In the end it was all farming consumables and grabbing world buffs. BC's greatness was tempered a bit by the persistence of some bad ideas from vanilla (really, from content designers who carried grudges from Everquest). Cataclysm was so awful that I stopped playing for almost two years, and only came back because I moved someplace where it's too cold to do anything but gaming in the winter. MoP is amazing for leveling and quests, the world design is spectacular, but it suffers from many of Cataclysm's endgame flaws...the "no, u no can has" content design philosophy is really starting to drive people away, I fear.

[frogger237]

7/9 for all of them. (i never rate anything a 10 so my system is out of 9)

[chrisisvacant]

Vanilla: 6
BC: 8
Wrath: 7
Cataclysm: 7
MOP: 9

[sdkphoenix]

BC: 6/10
WoTLK: 8/10
Cata: 7/10
MoP: 9/10

Vanilla wasn't an expac, but just looking at what it offered compared to the expansions, I'd give it a 6 out of 10.

[worsthitmanNa]

Vanilla: 6
Bc: 7
Wotlk: 5(mostly just burned out and all the stupid imbalances are the only thing popping up in my head.
Cata: 8
Mop:8

[Deleted]

MoP = 7/10 ( Recently came back. It's ok except for the stupid damage and stat numbers )

I agree on the stupid damage and stat numbers

as for the ratings,
vanilla (9/10)
tbc (8/10)
wotlk(9/10) This is where achievements got in,(actually it was in tbc, but it was the pre-Wotlk patch if I remember correctly)
it greatly increased the options of things to do and reasons to do them.
cata (7/10) (Rework of azeroth was amazing on most parts!)
MoP (8/10) (haven't leveled trough pandaria entirely yet and haven't raided/pvp'd on lvl 90 yet either so I guess I cant really tell , but I like it so far!)

[twh]

What I played of Vanilla: 5/10
TBC: 8/10
WoLK: 7/10
Cata: 2/10
Mop: 9/10

[Deleted]

Vanilla = 9/10
TBC = 10/10
Wotlk = 7/10
Cata = 8/10
MoP = 8/10

[Touridion]

Vanilla:6/10
TBC:9/10
WotLK:10/10
Cata:7/20
MOP:2/20

[Deletedaccount1]

BC- 5
Wrath - 9
Cata - 7
MoP- 8

[Beefkow]

Vanilla: didn't play
TBC: 7/10- Wasn't really active
WotLK: 8/10- Unholy dks were fun to play (not because they were OP)
Cata: 7/10- Great expac, but warriors got a BIG nerf bat so i just stopped playing
MOP:3/10- Terrible content, this expac i consider the worst pvp state in the history of wow

[chrisisvacant]

Vanilla: didn't play
TBC: 7/10- Wasn't really active
WotLK: 8/10- Unholy dks were fun to play (not because they were OP)
Cata: 7/10- Great expac, but warriors got a BIG nerf bat so i just stopped playing
MOP:3/10- Terrible content, this expac i consider the worst pvp state in the history of wow

So, you clearly don't like WoW. Why do you even play?

[Beefkow]

So, you clearly don't like WoW. Why do you even play?

Only for 1 expansion, plus my brother was hogging the computer for the entire TBC expansion, hence i never got to play alot, the only negative thing i said was warrior nerf bat towards the end of cata and MOP, other than that wow is an "OK" game.

[Phasma]

Based on the time of release:

Vanilla - 10/10 (no other game like it)
BC - 10/10
WoTLK - 8.5/10
Cataclysm - 6/10
MoP - 6/10

Based on today's MMO standards:

Vanilla - 3/10
BC - 7/10
WoTLK - 7/10
Cataclysm - 4/10
MoP - 4.5/10