BMAH "successful"? Not from where I sit.

[KrazyK923]

Its a gold sink.

If players sink gold on it, then its a success.

Players have sunk gold on it.

Therefore, it is a success.

[rated]

BMAH has not been a success for me. Have nothing against the feature it's just every time I've ever gone there all expansion I see lvl 60 transmog bracers or 20+ brawlers guild invites.

[Chaosturn]

It's not supposed to gear you up for heroic raiding, it's a goldsink.

[Tinykong]

BMAH has deleted over 4 million gold from my server in the last 30 days. I'd say it's successful.

[khalltusk]

BMAH is greatI was sick of farming for the hilt in the ICC 5mans and saw it on BMAH for 10k bought it completed the quest.

[dd614]

I'm not one for vanity items that I can't earn through gameplay, so I didn't partake in the BMAH in MoP. I have no problem with others spending tons of gold on vanity stuff. I'd personally take current raid gear off of it though because it kills immersion in the game.

I will say that most players I knew who pounded gold into the BMAH were gold buyers, which kind of sucks. Though I suppose getting excesses of gold out of the marketplace was the point.

[Zyrinx]

The problem with the BHAH is the one cool item and 14 Brawlers invites.

[Orcindauh]

It could do with less Brawlers guild invites.

This, too many damn brawlers guild invites and hardly anyone is buying them anymore.