Best tank class 1V1 wargame

[CaptQuebec]

In your opinion, what would be the best overall 1v1 tank class with PVP template enabled (ex: Wargame 10 players 1V1).
1) Protection Warrior
2) Protection Paladin
3) Bear druid
4) Blood DK
5) Vengeance DH
6) Brewmaster monk

By overall, I mean the class that would get the highest win ratio versus melee and range classes.

[Deleted]

That depends on what you wanna do. An Flag carrying VDH ist almost impossible to catch.

[CaptQuebec]

That depends on what you wanna do. An Flag carrying VDH ist almost impossible to catch.

For 1v1 with PvP template on.

It does not mean I wont do RBGs or Arena, but my question was in the context of a 1v1 with PvP templates.

[Saverem]

That depends on what you wanna do. An Flag carrying VDH ist almost impossible to catch.

Pretty much what this guy says.

Are you talking about an arena style 1v1? If so, then that is a tricky question because some tanks would probably be immortal against each other.

ie a Prot Pally vs a BDK would pretty much never die against each other. BDKs will have endless heals, and Prot Pally could CC/kite BDK and heal himself back up behind a pillar.

Same with BrMs/Drus who can CC/kite and heal themselves.


If there's an objective to do like CTF, then there would be no question that VDHs would reign supreme. Prot Warriors will also be good at this as would Guardians.

[CaptQuebec]

Pretty much what this guy says.

Are you talking about an arena style 1v1? If so, then that is a tricky question because some tanks would probably be immortal against each other.

ie a Prot Pally vs a BDK would pretty much never die against each other. BDKs will have endless heals, and Prot Pally could CC/kite BDK and heal himself back up behind a pillar.

Same with BrMs/Drus who can CC/kite and heal themselves.


If there's an objective to do like CTF, then there would be no question that VDHs would reign supreme. Prot Warriors will also be good at this as would Guardians.

It is in the context of 1v1 wargame (if you watch Dalaran streams , he does these organized 1v1 on a regular basis, 2 teams of 5 enter the arena and they have 1v1 until there is only one player left), no flag carrying, just duel with PvP templates.

I did notice that he only has DPS class dueling (rogues, monks, hunters, pallys, mages, etc.), so maybe its because tanks or healer would drag the duels too long, or is it because they would stand no chance vs DPS ?

[Deleted]

It is in the context of 1v1 wargame (if you watch Dalaran streams , he does these organized 1v1 on a regular basis, 2 teams of 5 enter the arena and they have 1v1 until there is only one player left), no flag carrying, just duel with PvP templates.

I did notice that he only has DPS class dueling (rogues, monks, hunters, pallys, mages, etc.), so maybe its because tanks or healer would drag the duels too long, or is it because they would stand no chance vs DPS ?

Like Saverem said, as a Tank you would be pretty much unkillable. There is no point to 1v1 a Tank, especially if both teams have one. It's pretty much a lose-lose situation.