Originally Posted by
Marrilaife
I don't know that much from a pvp standpoint except "human racial was op in WOD pvp", but from pve standpoint top guilds always converged on horde, causing their fans, followers and mimics pick horde too, so we have a mythic raider ratio atm of something like 70:30 in favour of horde, and the higher in ranks you go, the less alliance guilds you see. The fotm racial changed across times (orc > troll > blood elf / goblin recently), but the only race that had "good pve racial" and was accessible on the alliance ever was MOP panda double food buff, but the potency of this racial is dependent on the state of consumables in specific expansions, and it was accessible to horde too.
Same problem with m+ ladder and dominant blood elves. I expect nerfing aoe stuns (like dh stun being changed to disorient) is gonna make the new highmountain racial (stun charge) more in demand as stuns from class abilities are less potent and less common.
I'm not sure if any change now can help, but during Legion I noticed as the raiding population shrank, alliance was depopulating much faster than horde, which was converging on the 4-5 megaservers and still going strong in the EU region I'm playing. No idea if it's any different in the US, feel free to chip in if you know how it is across the pond. But in EU it wasn't an uncommon sight to see an alliance player on wowprogress look for a guild and say he only wants horde guilds to escape his low pop alliance server with no perspectives, and of course horde players would say "alliance guilds I have no interest in".
While Bllizzard took some measures to stop alliance depopulation after nerfing human racial in pvp by saying titles for arena / rbg are gonna be faction split, there is no help so far for pve communities, and obviously a strict stance against letting players of opposite factions group together in pve content (or any content at all, but in pve it would at least be less offensive). At the moment there is literally 1 server on EU English with surviving and healthy Alliance mythic raiding community - Ravencrest. Servers like Silvermoon, Sylvanas or Frostmane that used to be bastions of Alliance raiding have extremely diminished number of successful guilds in comparison to the days long gone. Everything is slowly going towards "horde or die" and I'm not sure if void elves can do anything to stop the trend. Even if racials were removed now (which they won't, as Blizzard is strongly against it), once a faction has superior numbers of noticeable disparity, people are gonna flock to the dominating faction - this is true both in server populations, and in the bigger picture region wide.
Designing complete garbo racials like lightforged Draenei doesn't help the cause. I'm a Draenei fan and I liked the Lightforged appearances from the moment I saw them on the Vindicaar, but I find myself hard pressed to even consider them as an alt because of the clunky idea behind their racials, I'd take my small primary stat buff of a normal Draenei over a targeted, delayed blast that half the time won't land because the target will be moved or die before it fires. And let's be honest, Blizzard won't allow it to scale out of control because of pvp issues ("he stunned me and 1 shot me with racial"), so it's gonna be pathetic like touch of the grave, but half the time won't even land. This is nearly as stupid as quaking palm (don't think anyone ever thinks that was a good racial, melee range single target incapacitate that breaks on damage), but at least pandas get the double food buff.