Official High Elf Discussion Megathread

[Tanaria]

I am not sure how night elves are enveloped into human potential. We had at least three expansions heavily centered around night elves. So this is obv. not an argument
Apart from this, blood elves did never fit into the horde because the whole aestetics is completly different.

Well neither did Trolls, Undead, Tauren, Goblins, Pandaren, Vulpera, Nightborne as well as many others, but the Horde is not just, the Orcs.
Unfortunately, the Alliance writers haven't quite received the memo that the Alliance isn't just the Humans.

Did we forget "Human Potential: Shandris Feathermoon 2018."
Keep doing you, Shandris, darling. Your a credit to the Kaldorei.

[Eggroll]

I am not sure how night elves are enveloped into human potential. We had at least three expansions heavily centered around night elves. So this is obv. not an argument
Apart from this, blood elves did never fit into the horde because the whole aestetics is completly different.

Only in the way that the human Alliance leader got almost all of them killed by neglect. Ooopsie.

[Tanaria]

Only in the way that the human Alliance leader got almost all of them killed by neglect. Ooopsie.

I'll call Shandris and tell her about your outdated views on the Humans.

[Eggroll]

I'll call Shandris and tell her about your outdated views on the Humans.

Maybe she'll see the error of her ways now she's with Ysera at the Heart of the Forest, far away from any "human potential", so she can detox and clear her mind

[Pheraz]

Well neither did Trolls, Undead, Tauren, Goblins, Pandaren, Vulpera, Nightborne as well as many others, but the Horde is not just, the Orcs.
Unfortunately, the Alliance writers haven't quite received the memo that the Alliance isn't just the Humans.

Did we forget "Human Potential: Shandris Feathermoon 2018."
Keep doing you, Shandris, darling. Your a credit to the Kaldorei.

If you feel personally comfortable inside stinky tends in oggrimar as a blood elf, fine. But objectively it makes zero sense from either perspective

[Tanaria]

If you feel personally comfortable inside stinky tends in oggrimar as a blood elf, fine. But objectively it makes zero sense from either perspective

Well no, considering the Blood Elf homeland is Quel'Thalas. Quel'Thalas is Horde land.

I mean, for those Blood Elves who do spend time in Orgrimmar, at least they still get screen time.

I mean, you could literally delete every Alliance race and just have the faction as "Humans" and the story would hardly be affected.

[Pheraz]

Well no, considering the Blood Elf homeland is Quel'Thalas. Quel'Thalas is Horde land.

I mean, for those Blood Elves who do spend time in Orgrimmar, at least they still get screen time.

I mean, you could literally delete every Alliance race and just have the faction as "Humans" and the story would hardly be affected.

The only reason blooed elves are in the horde is because chinese female players wanted a pretty race.
Same as Teldrassil only burned because they needed a plot device for their weird SL story. Some pills are bitter, I know.

[Varodoc]

Here's a few more looks using the black and white with void skin tones. I especially like the death knight! Reminds me of Lady Death!

Very well done with the middle one, it's how I would imagine a Ren'dorei paladin. Did you base it on that concept?

[Tanaria]

The only reason blooed elves are in the horde is because chinese female players wanted a pretty race.
Same as Teldrassil only burned because they needed a plot device for their weird SL story. Some pills are bitter, I know.

The only reason why alliance got void elfs, was because alliance wanted to play with the thalassian model. And in case you've forgotten, the Blood Elves left the alliance in W3.

The stones were already set for the Sin'dorei to join the Horde or remain neutral-horde friendly. W3 events, Sylvanas joining the Horde...all there. You just need to accept that those aspects are not for you, if your not going to play Horde. Stick to the faction of "Humans and Pals."

[Pheraz]

The only reason why alliance got void elfs, was because alliance wanted to play with the thalassian model.

This is abs. correct.
As I said, factions and are super weird in WoW. Nothing makes really sense, but imo the horde makes the least sense High elves/blood elves should never be in a faction of monsters. makes no sense, sorry.

[Tanaria]

This is abs. correct.
As I said, factions and are super weird in WoW. Nothing makes really sense, but imo the horde makes the least sense High elves/blood elves should never be in a faction of monsters. makes no sense, sorry.

And stereotyping the Horde is what makes me not like the Alliance fanbase. I don't know what it is with people like you who thinks they can dictate what each faction should be, but the Alliance is allowed to be a bit darker, but the Horde...NO! Must be only ORCS AND MONSTERS!!!!! RAWWWRR!

If you want the Horde to be "Sauron: LOTR Army" sort of thing, just play LOTRO. Azeroth is NOT Middle Earth. Sorry, but it's just fact.

I'm sorry that the alliance has crap writing with everything being about Humans. That's not the Horde fanbase's problem.

[Pheraz]

And stereotyping the Horde is what makes me not like the Alliance fanbase. I don't know what it is with people like you who thinks they can dictate what each faction should be, but the Alliance is allowed to be a bit darker, but the Horde...NO! Must be only ORCS AND MONSTERS!!!!! RAWWWRR!

If you want the Horde to be "Sauron: LOTR Army" sort of thing, just play LOTRO. Azeroth is NOT Middle Earth. Sorry, but it's just fact.

I'm sorry that the alliance has crap writing with everything being about Humans. That's not the Horde fanbase's problem.

Yes, elves do not fit within a monster faction. It is a video game with proper aestetics and when I see something that does not fit I say it.
Like... A B A B A B A B A B A B A B Y A B A B A B. Yes, the Y does not fit. I don't understand why you, or at least it looks like this, are so touchy about it.
The horde has BEs because chinese female players wanted a pretty race. There is no other reason. It is the only reason. There is no deep lore connection or anything. I don't understand why you come up with that LOTR example all the time. There are more fantasy universes out there, and none of them has elves together with orcs and trolls. Apart from ofc.. DARK elves.

[MyWholeLifeIsThunder]

If you feel personally comfortable inside stinky tends in oggrimar as a blood elf, fine. But objectively it makes zero sense from either perspective

I mean to be honest for Blood Elves Orgimmar wouldn't feel all that more different from Stormwind.

Like the BE's that get out there clearly don't mind it, and the ones that do, well, they really wouldn't see much of a difference between Orcs and Humans lmao.

What I really don't like about the "Blood Elves make no sense on the Horde" is that, well, High Elves didn't make "sense" in the Alliance either, they joined in the second war out of necessity, not out of love. Of course some High Elves fell in love with the alliance and its people, but that's as much as true for some Blood Elves now on the Horde.

To say "objectively make zero sense" is just kinda disingenuous. The realm of Quel'thalas isn't in the Horde for the good vibes; they are in there because of politics and mutual aid, the same reason they were on the Alliance back when.

A Thalassian that would look down on the way of life of Orcs and other Horde races, would most likely do the same for the alliance races, cause that's just Xenophobia.

But at the end, it's really just politics within the universe, and "aesthetics" are utterly irrelevant to that.

[elbleuet]

The only reason why alliance got void elfs, was because alliance wanted to play with the thalassian model. And in case you've forgotten, the Blood Elves left the alliance in W3.

The stones were already set for the Sin'dorei to join the Horde or remain neutral-horde friendly. W3 events, Sylvanas joining the Horde...all there. You just need to accept that those aspects are not for you, if your not going to play Horde. Stick to the faction of "Humans and Pals."

Hum... No.

QT was going to be Alliance. Even in Vanilla, a faction named as Remnants of Silvermoon was introduced on the ptr (but never got implemented on live).
And there was an Alliance high elve on the road leading QT hinting that Silvermoon was going to be Alliance.

So no. Blood elves are Horde for gameplay and marketing reasons.

And no we never wanted the thalassian model. We just wanted the Alliance to be complete again.

[Tanaria]

Yes, elves do not fit within a monster faction. It is a video game with proper aestetics and when I see something that does not fit I say it.
Like... A B A B A B A B A B A B A B Y A B A B A B. Yes, the Y does not fit. I don't understand why you, or at least it looks like this, are so touchy about it.
The horde has BEs because chinese female players wanted a pretty race. There is no other reason. It is the only reason. There is no deep lore connection or anything. I don't understand why you come up with that LOTR example all the time. There are more fantasy universes out there, and none of them has elves together with orcs and trolls. Apart from ofc.. DARK elves.

And when I see something that is bad story, I say it. Alliance story is bad. It's a meme at this point.

The Horde has Blood Elves because the story was set up from W3. They left the alliance because of racism.
You just don't like that story set up because it took things you like, to the faction you don't like. Not my problem, I'm afraid.

- - - Updated - - -

Hum... No.

QT was going to be Alliance. Even in Vanilla, a faction named as Remnants of Silvermoon was introduced on the ptr (but never got implemented on live).
And there was an Alliance high elve on the road leading QT hinting that Silvermoon was going to be Alliance.

So no. Blood elves are Horde for gameplay and marketing reasons.

And no we never wanted the thalassian model. We just wanted the Alliance to be complete again.

Your just ignoring the racism behind why the Blood Elves left the alliance.

again, it's taking features you like to the faction you don't like. Its not my fault your Alliance has crap writing which makes everything about the Humans. Honestly, I'm all for deleting the alliance races, barring Humans, at this point, because it wouldn't actually impact on the Alliance story.

Get over the Sin'dorei, Quel'Thalas and Silvermoon already.

[Pheraz]

And when I see something that is bad story, I say it. Alliance story is bad. It's a meme at this point.

The Horde has Blood Elves because the story was set up from W3. They left the alliance because of racism.
You just don't like that story set up because it took things you like, to the faction you don't like. Not my problem, I'm afraid.

- - - Updated - - -



Your just ignoring the racism behind why the Blood Elves left the alliance.

again, it's taking features you like to the faction you don't like. Its not my fault your Alliance has crap writing which makes everything about the Humans. Honestly, I'm all for deleting the alliance races, barring Humans, at this point, because it wouldn't actually impact on the Alliance story.

Jesus (I don't believe in Jesus, but I like to say "Jesus"), can someone please get him this official quote from blizzard...

[Tanaria]

Jesus (I don't believe in Jesus, but I like to say "Jesus"), can someone please get him this official quote from blizzard...

I've seen the quote - but you still don't like the story from W3 which was set up.
Again, you just don't like that story.

[MyWholeLifeIsThunder]

Hum... No.

QT was going to be Alliance. Even in Vanilla, a faction named as Remnants of Silvermoon was introduced on the ptr (but never got implemented on live).
And there was an Alliance high elve on the road leading QT hinting that Silvermoon was going to be Alliance.

So no. Blood elves are Horde for gameplay and marketing reasons.

And no we never wanted the thalassian model. We just wanted the Alliance to be complete again.

We can't confirm that's true tho; like yeah, we can make a pretty good Guess that High Elves could have been an alliance race, but Quel'thalas and the blood elves themselves? I think we were actually closer to them being enemies on a future expansion rather than Silvermoon being alliance.

Considering the ended up splitting the BE into "good" and "bad" ones, I think it is the far more likely scenario.

[Pheraz]

I've seen the quote - but you still don't like the story from W3 which was set up.
Again, you just don't like that story.

Great, so why are we still agueing? I even said mult. times that silvermoon is fine as it is. No one wants to take your precious blood elves from the stinky tends of derpimarr. I don't understand why you seem to be so defensiv about BEs all the time. There is stuff that is just fact and why we ended up where we are.

[Tanaria]

Great, so why are we still agueing? I even said mult. times that silvermoon is fine as it is. No one wants to take your precious blood elves from the stinky tends of derpimarr. I don't understand why you seem to be so defensiv about BEs all the time. There is stuff that is just fact and why we ended up where we are.

Silvermoon is not fine the way it is. Silvermoon needs updating for Horde Blood Elves.
The city looks like a poor-man's GTA Vice City from the PS2 era. The Exodar is the same.

I mean why are we arguing? You've got your High Elves in Stormwind...? A decent and fitting city, all things considered..? Horde have Blood Elves with an unfinished Silvermoon.